DEAR MISS MANNERS: My sister likes to throw dinner parties. She goes all out with her best dishes and crystal, along with the menu. Often people will call and ask what to bring, but my sister always tells them she only wants the pleasure of their company.
Some guests will still bring a dish. My sister always acts like the dish is a hostess gift. She thanks the guests and tells them how much her family will enjoy it.
On one occasion, a first-time guest brought a dish. She told my sister she had not brought the dish for my sister's family, but to be served to the other guests. My sister told her that the menu was set, and that she would put the dish in the kitchen until the guest was ready to leave so they could take it home.
During the meal, when another guest was complimenting my sister on the food, this guest announced to everybody that she had brought a dish that my sister was not going to serve. My sister ignored her comment and answered another guest's question.
Since the dinner, this woman has been telling people how rude my sister was not to serve the food she brought. Her comments have upset our mother. She wants my sister to apologize to this woman.
My sister sees no reason to apologize. To make my mother happy, I said we should ask you. Was my sister rude?
GENTLE READER: Well, there are traditional dinner parties, where the host supplies the meal and the guests may or may not bring little presents -- sometimes food treats -- to be used at the discretion of the host. And then there are cooperative dinners, where each person brings part of the meal.
This sounds more like a food fight. Rather than trying to please the host, the guest planned a hostile takeover. And afterward, when she should have been expressing her thanks, she chose to spread insults.
No, your sister was not rude. She did her best to handle it politely. But there are circumstances under which an apology is due, even from an innocent person.
So Miss Manners believes that your sister should apologize -- not to her rude guest, but to the other guests, for having been subjected to such an unpleasant scene.