DEAR MISS MANNERS: After asking my dinner guests not to bring any dishes, some still do. My question is what do do when Person A shows up with a dish, and Person B -- lovely, lovely Person B, who was polite and kind enough to take me at my word -- sees the exchange.
Person B invariably gets embarrassed and asks if they should have brought something. I usually say, “Oh, no! This is not a potluck. Person A just had a dish she really wanted to share.”
But inside, I am screaming, “No, Person B, you have manners -- unlike this completely overbearing person!”
The problem is that B is never comfortable with my answer, even if I talk to them later and explain what happened. It's a very awkward situation.
I’m not worried about getting through to Person A; they’re a lost cause. But how do I make things right for B, who is absolutely a dream dinner guest?
GENTLE READER: Short of dropping Person A’s dish on Person A’s foot, the way to demonstrate to Person B that they were correct to take you at your word is to go about your evening.
When you speak to Person B alone, add that you are most grateful for the courtesy of being listened to. Miss Manners is sure that that, coupled with your evident passion on the subject, will leave Person B in no doubt as to how you truly feel.