DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: When is the right time to ask someone out? Is it ok to ask a person for their number when you’ve only just met them? What if you’re not sure if they’re flirting with you or not?��I’ve had a lot of conversations with people where it seemed like maybe they were flirting with me or like we had the beginning of a moment, but I would always chicken out and not say anything when we were done and then I would regret it afterwards. Now I’m older and still single and I’m tired of feeling like I’ve been missing out on chances. Is it ok for me to just make a move, even if I’m not 100% sure that the other person is flirting with me or not?
Tired Of Missing Out
DEAR TIRED OF MISSING OUT: This is a question where the answer is “That depends…”. Now, I get it: that is both unhelpful and profoundly unsatisfying an answer. But the fact of the matter is that, as much as we might prefer it, there aren’t a lot of hard and fast rules as to when is the ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ time to ask someone for a date or their number or what-have-you. For every rule, there’s someone who has broken it successfully, and plenty of people who follow the “rules” perfectly but without success. Most of what we have are best practices, general rules of thumb and a few situations that are a “best not” – and all of them are influenced by factors like context, social skill level and experience, and circumstance.
The harder “don’t’s”, for example, tend to be about safety and power. A boss hitting on their employee is an example of a massive power imbalance; the boss may have the best and most honest of intentions, but they’re still a person who can decide whether or not their employee has a job. This puts a lot of pressure on the employee to say “yes”, even if the boss would never exploit their power that way.
A context where the answer isn’t “no” but “not the best idea”, on the other hand, is one where the odds of misreading things are higher. People in service industry jobs or jobs that rely on tips, for example, have an incentive to be nice or even flirty with customers. A bartender who flirts a bit with a customer is more likely to get a bigger tip when they close out, as does a waitress who leaves a doodle of a smiley face and a “thank you” on the bill. A dancer at a strip club is motivated to encourage customers to buy private dances and an OnlyFans model will tease and entice subscribers to buy videos or services they offer. They have a strong financial incentive to play up to the customer’s desire to help move that along. It’s easy for someone to let horny thinking get out ahead of them and assume that there’s more going on than a service professional/customer relationship.
In circumstances like this, you’re not forbidden from asking them out, but it’s highly unlikely to go anywhere. While it’s not impossible – people have asked out bar staff or waitresses or dancers successfully – it’s better to err on the side of “not”, just so you don’t waste time or risk embarrassment.
It’s also important to be able to read the room. Some places are simply not the time to try to hit on someone or get their number. A networking event or a professional setting is usually not the time or place for trying to make a more personal connection. The same applies to, say, yoga classes or other group events; a lot of people – mostly men – tend to treat them as sex ATMs and end up creating an uncomfortable atmosphere for the people who are just there to work on their flow.
But this is also where social calibration and social experience come into play. There’s a difference between someone who goes to hot yoga or a dance class and acts like a horny hyena looking for a limping gazelle and someone who’s there for the class and is just being social. Talking with folks and making a connection that eventually leads to asking them on a date is very different than someone who’s only there because that’s where the hot people are and couldn’t care less about their Salute to the Sun.
Someone who is very good at reading the room and has a solid level of social skill and experience is also more likely to be able to discern – correctly – when a specific situation is an exception, and the person they’re talking to would be receptive to a date or giving their number. That, however, is born out of experience and the understanding that exceptions are just that – exceptions. If you have to ask if this is an exception, the answer is almost certainly “no”. And if you’re asking me if it’s ok to ask someone you’ve just met out on a date… well, it doesn’t sound like you’ve reached that level of skill yet.
But if we’re talking about casual conversation with a stranger or acquaintance – one that’s more than perfunctory small talk or a conversation in passing… that can be a little different. If you’ve been having a good conversation with someone in line at Starbucks, or that you just met at a party, there’s nothing wrong with saying “Hey, I’ve really enjoyed talking to you; is it ok if I give you my number?” or “I’ve got to go but I would really like to talk to you again; may I add you on WhatsApp/Messenger/Instagram/$INSERT_MESSAGING_PLATFORM_HERE?”
The key in this case, is that you’re putting the ball in their court. By offering your number or WhatsApp ID, you’re giving them the chance to decide whether they want to take the next step or not. It’s less of an imposition; you’re not asking them to make a decision now, so much as giving them the option of doing so later. It’s a little easier to say “yes” to the opportunity to say “ok, that guy was pretty charming, I’ll give him a text tomorrow” than decide if they want to roll the dice on you right then and there.
A thing to keep in mind is that missing out on opportunities isn’t the end of the world, especially if you aren’t sure there was an opportunity to miss out on. There will be other opportunities, especially if you are making an effort to be social and meet people in general. But if you can just enjoy having conversations with people and vibing with them, you’ll start building the skill and refining the calibration that will make it easier to know when someone’s into you and when someone is just enjoying talking to a stranger and doesn’t want anything more than that.
Oh, and one last tip: if you’re unsure if someone’s flirting… just ask. There’s a minor risk of embarrassment in asking, but the embarrassment from asking and being told “no” is a lot less than the embarrassment of guessing and guessing wrong. Plus, a well-delivered “…are you flirting with me?” can be a hell of a sexy line, especially if the answer is yes.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com