Just when I thought we had become numb to state-directed cruelty and injustice -- that our outrage was spent, that we needed to look away from the burning embers of American democracy to preserve our own sanity -- a video so horrific emerged that it reignited the full anguish and anger this moment deserves.
We watched ICE agent Jonathan Ross repeatedly shoot Renee Good, killing the 37-year-old Minneapolis mother who had just dropped her 6-year-old daughter off at school.
A brown puppy stuffed animal spilled out of the glove compartment of her blood-splattered car.
A video released by the Department of Homeland Security captured Good's last words to Ross: “That’s fine, I’m not mad at you.” The same video captures what an ICE agent (potentially Ross) uttered at her after she was shot three times: “Fucking bitch.”
The video shows Ross holding a gun in one hand and a cellphone, to keep filming, in the other. As one does when they are terrified for their life.
Before any investigation even began, DHS Secretary Kristi Noem said the agent acted in self-defense and called Good a “domestic terrorist.” But multiple journalistic outlets and legal analysts examined video footage frame-by-frame from various angles. The footage at least suggests that Good's SUV was moving away and not attempting to strike the agent when shots were fired.
The FBI is investigating the shooting, but state and local authorities have been blocked from viewing its findings. Six federal prosecutors have resigned over the Justice Department’s handling of the investigation.
Polling conducted shortly after the killing shows that 35% of respondents believe Ross’ shooting of Good was justified.
The government narrative that citizens must “comply or die” drives home the reality of the past year: We are living under a far-right government that embraces authoritarian tactics.
People in many parts of the world have been experiencing rising authoritarianism and a global decline in democratic norms. Global democracy scores have dropped to historic lows.
What this looks like in practice is tighter control of the media and civil society, challenges to judicial independence, manipulating or weakening the electoral process, suppressing dissent and protest, and consolidating power.
As one of the world’s oldest continuous constitutional democracies, it’s shocking to see America’s backslide and realize how few safeguards we had against this. In recent elections, far-right parties in Europe have won around 25% of the vote. The strongest showing has been in France, where the far-right captured about 31% -- a record high -- in the European Parliament election in 2024.
The 35% who said they support ICE’s killing of Good likely share the worldview and beliefs of those voters. What they fail to realize is that no citizen is safe under an authoritarian government. Not a single one. Even if you never attend a single protest or speak a word of politics, you still need fair courts, stable laws that apply equally, guaranteed rights, and truthful and accurate information from authorities.
Every citizen loses legal, economic and social protections under the far right.
When people can no longer trust the government or media to tell them the truth, it’s harder to make daily decisions about your health, safety and financial choices. Authoritarians weaken the social safety net and labor protections and undermine independent economic institutions. (Jerome Powell, the Fed chair facing investigation, can attest to this.) Far-right groups shift the definition of who counts as fully deserving citizens worthy of protection -- excluding those who challenge them in any regard.
When the law is less predictable, there is less protection against the abuse of power and less recourse for those harmed by the state or those it favors.
If armed federal agents approached you, which mindset would you want them to have?
You could “comply or die,” as insisted by those who support ICE’s actions. You may have seconds to “comply” with conflicting instructions shouted by armed, masked agents in a chaotic situation.
But there’s another way of walking in this world. One that invokes the name of a woman we cannot forget: Be Good.