DEAR NATALIE: My partner and I are politically divided and it’s starting to affect our finances. We’ve always known we vote differently, but lately it’s become more than dinner table debate. He’s been donating significant amounts of money to MAGA candidates and causes I strongly oppose, and I recently discovered he dipped into our joint savings to do it. We both work full-time and agreed to pool most of our income, but now I’m questioning whether we need separate accounts, or even separate financial futures. He says I’m overreacting and that political giving is no different than any other charitable donation. I feel blindsided and worry this is less about money and more about values. How do couples navigate financial transparency when their political identities feel like moral identities? – MONEY MATTERS
DEAR MONEY MATTERS: If you’re sharing an account, it should follow that the money pooled there is used for mutually agreed-upon purposes like shared expenses, vacations or long-term goals. If your husband is determined to give large sums to candidates and causes you oppose, two things need to happen. In the short term, it needs to stop. If he wants to spend money that way — and I mean his money, saved separately from your joint account — that is his decision. But funds should not be taken from a shared savings account for political donations without your consent. Period. In the long term, you need a serious conversation about your priorities and your shared vision for the future, both financially and relationally. If supporting candidates whose policies you believe harm you or your community conflicts with your core values, that isn’t a small disagreement. It’s a fundamental one. It’s difficult to build a stable future with someone who disregards your perspective, and diverting shared resources to causes that contradict your values can damage more than your bank balance. It can erode trust. The real question is how much he is willing to prioritize your partnership over politics. You deserve clarity on that and then you can decide your next steps accordingly.
DEAR NATALIE: My parents want to “retire” but they have no savings and expect me to step in. I’m in my early 30s, still paying off student loans and saving for my own kids’ college funds. My parents spent years helping extended family overseas and sending money to relatives, which I respect, but they didn’t build a retirement cushion. Now they’re hinting that moving in with us — and relying on us financially — is the natural next step. I feel torn between cultural expectations, genuine love for them and resentment that their lack of planning may derail my own family’s stability. My spouse is supportive but nervous about what this means long term. How do I set boundaries without feeling like I’m abandoning them?
– PLANNING FOR WHAT’S NEXT
DEAR PLANNING FOR WHAT’S NEXT: It’s a big ask for your parents to expect to move in with you. While I appreciate that they want to retire, it isn’t your fault they chose to support extended family instead of setting aside a nest egg. At the same time, they are your parents, and you want to support them. So what are your options? You could give in and let them move in, which may put significant strain on your relationship with your husband and your family life. Or you could find another way to help that doesn’t involve sharing your current home. A third option would be for them to sell their home and for you to purchase a larger house — ideally one with an in-law suite — and share the mortgage. But if that isn’t realistic, especially given current mortgage rates, consider another approach. Start by connecting them with a financial planner who can take a close look at their finances and outline what a path to retirement might realistically look like. Having a plan in place could relieve some of the pressure on you to act immediately. There may be a solution that respects your boundaries while still providing your parents with meaningful support. Explore that first before anyone starts packing boxes.
Please send your questions to Natalie Bencivenga to
asknatalieadvice@gmail.com.
Watch her NEW show with WQED: Destination with Natalie Bencivenga at wqed.org
Watch her video series with Pennsylvania Capital Star, Week in Focus: www.penncapital-star.com
Follow Natalie on Instagram and TikTok @NatalieBencivenga
Subscribe to her newsletter on Substack: @FactsOverFearNatalieB