DEAR MISS MANNERS: I was at the dentist last week and the hygienist, whom I had never met before, mentioned she had a new grandchild. I naturally congratulated her and asked the polite questions: sex, name, etc.
Then she asked about my children, and I replied that I have one son. "Is he married?" No, but he's in a long-term relationship. "Any children?" No. "Don’t they want children?" ... Crickets.
This is not the first time someone has asked me these things. I wouldn’t ask my closest friend these questions about one of her children, let alone a stranger!
I had to return to the dentist the following week, and there was a different hygienist making small talk while we waited for the dentist. This time, I kept my answers to "yes" and "no," which felt rude.
I’ll admit, I am a bit sensitive about the subject; I would love to have a grandchild, but it’s not in the cards for me. Still, where do people get off asking such personal questions? And better yet, what’s a good reply to shut them down?
GENTLE READER: While Miss Manners agrees that this conversation jumped the rails, she does not understand why you were still holding on when it did.
The hygienist’s probing would have been insensitive with any new acquaintance, but was even more out of place in a professional setting. The moment the first personal question was asked -- assuming it was not part of a standard medical intake, performed in a private setting -- was the moment to smile graciously and ask where the bathroom was, or when the dentist would be ready to see you.