life

College Student Insulted for Style

Miss Manners by by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Miss Manners | June 14th, 2011

DEAR MISS MANNERS: I have always admired the beautiful dresses and jewelry that my grandmothers and my mother have worn. I have been fortunate to have the women in my family teach me how to sew all of my own clothes, cross-stitch and embroidery. They also presented a lovely birthstone pearl necklace for my high school graduation, which I wear on a daily basis.

I am a 19-year-old college student, but I do not like to dress in "modern fashions" as defined by my fellow students (torn jeans and revealing tops), but dress in handmade tailored jackets and dresses with heels. When the weather is cold, I wear hand-sewn moccasins beaded by family members who still live on a Native American reservation, with jeans.

I am often taunted by fellow students, but I am now insulted by random strangers in public as to why I don't "dress my own age," and choose to take cues from my grandmothers instead.

I tell them that I feel more comfortable and "more myself" in these styles, but the insults still keep coming. How do I let these people know that I do not appreciate their, as they state, "constructive criticism"?

GENTLE READER: You have just demonstrated, once again, that people who vehemently defend their own sloppiness as "being comfortable" and practicing self-expression -- as in "This is who I am" -- are unable to tolerate others' claiming the same.

What is more, their idea of dressing one's age is out-of-date. About the only difference between generations that Miss Manners has noticed lately is that older people tend not to see the charm in buying blue jeans with the rips already in them.

The unspoken college dress code nowadays is informal, but that covers a range, and jeans, moccasins, jackets and sporty dresses fall within that range.

Of course no one should be critiquing your clothes as long as you are decently dressed. A paralyzing rejoinder is to say "Thank you for the compliment."

DEAR MISS MANNERS: When we have a party at our home, my stepdaughter-to-be always is the one to park in our driveway. I feel it is rude and would never park in someone's driveway without permission (kids in the car or not).

My fiance does not agree. Is it rude to park in someone's driveway without permission when they come over to visit?

GENTLE READER: "Someone's" driveway? Wasn't it her father's driveway? And, for that matter, her future stepmother's?

If you have a reason that she should not park there, surely you ought to be able to say, "Please park on the street, dear -- I like the driveway to be free so that my mother has less far to walk." Or "because you're blocking the caterer's truck."

Otherwise, Miss Manners advises you to not try to twist typical family behavior into a generalized etiquette problem. She would have thought that this would be a time that you would be especially eager to make your fiance's daughter feel part of the new family.

DEAR MISS MANNERS: When should you write a bread-and-butter letter?

GENTLE READER: When you have consumed bread and butter at the home of someone else.

Can Miss Manners trust you to understand that this is not to be taken literally, and that the bread stands for a meal and the butter for hospitality?

:

life

Cooking Up Resentment in Boyfriend’s Kitchen

Miss Manners by by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Miss Manners | June 12th, 2011

DEAR MISS MANNERS: My boyfriend of a year was approached by two female friends of his asking for a night out of the city to visit him in the suburbs for dinner.

After asking me, we agreed to host a dinner party for the four of us in his home. I have yet to meet these friends and thought it would be fun to host a party and get to know them.

Upon further discussion of what I thought I would cook for the evening, I learned that these two ladies plan on cooking for us. Apparently, that was part of the idea, to get out of the city where their kitchens are small and to cook in a larger kitchen.

I feel like this it is rude of them, but am not sure, since it is technically not my kitchen, as we do not yet live together. I certainly would never invite myself to cook in another person's home.

Am I overreacting? What is the polite way to signal I am planning the menu and if they would like to bring a side that would be wonderful?

GENTLE READER: Funny that you haven't mentioned the gentleman's reaction.

They are his friends, and it is his kitchen. And while there are people who hate having others working in their kitchens, the offer, which they can simply decline with thanks, is not rude.

So Miss Manners will address herself to your question about overreacting.

Her guess is that this strikes you as the ladies' thinking it would be cute to feed the helpless bachelor who must be in need of some feminine care. And that you are bristling because this would ignore your attachment.

You would be well advised to drop that whole idea. They know about you, they have shown interest in meeting you, and you should accede graciously to their offer, which Miss Manners suspects that the gentleman has already accepted.

Besides, nothing will emphasize the two of you being a couple more than jointly allowing these friends to pamper you.

DEAR MISS MANNERS: At least several times a month, I receive "warnings" from well-intentioned friends. These are usually messages that have been forwarded many, many times, containing alerts about computer viruses, credit card scams, health issues, dying children yearning for business cards and the like.

Trouble is, that when I check the accuracy of these well-meaning messages, the vast majority turn out to be false alarms, many of which have been circulating for years.

Of course I always ignore the "please forward this to all your friends," but what do I do vis a vis the sender? It seems rude to return a message telling them they've alarmed folks unnecessarily, but my not doing so simply encourages them to continue the practice of sending on unverified information.

GENTLE READER: The phrase you need, if you wish to alert your friends to their mistakes, is "You will be relieved to hear that..."

Miss Manners' idea here is to show sympathy for their concern, thus enabling you to explain how you found out, thus possibly encouraging them to check themselves before sending out the alarm.

:

life

‘Ancient Mariner’ Restrains Reader at Church

Miss Manners by by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Miss Manners | June 9th, 2011

DEAR MISS MANNERS: Have you ever been physically restrained by someone so that she might continue her conversation?

Well, that is exactly what happened to me at church last week. I was exchanging pleasantries with an acquaintance while waiting on my husband to pick me up. When I saw him pull up, I said something along the lines of "Oh, that's George; he's out front in the car. It's been good to see you. (It hadn't.) I'll see you next Sunday."

Miss Manners, this woman reached out and took hold of my arm and held on to me to keep me there! She wasn't even trying to finish her sentence; she began talking on a new subject! I knew from past interaction that she doesn't seem to recognize polite social cues, but I didn't expect such selfish behavior.

I just kept smiling and backing away and agreeing sympathetically (the subject was her children) and reminding her that I really had to go and that I hoped George wasn't blocking the drive.

She was oblivious. I backed all the way to the door and there she released me. All in all, it took me about five minutes to "escape." I think she would've followed me out to the car if it hadn't been raining buckets. How should I handle this if it happens again?

GENTLE READER: Ah, so that's where the Ancient Mariner hangs out now.

As you may recall from the Coleridge poem, the classic victim of this treatment exclaims "Hold off! Unhand me, grey-beard loon!" but still can't get away. Fixed by the Ancient Mariner's glittering eye, he gives up and misses the wedding feast of his next-of-kin. only to endure 142 verses of sea story.

The next day, he counts himself a sadder and wiser man. Presumably that is because he has learned that "He prayeth best, who lovest best/All things both great and small" and therefore to avoid killing albatrosses. But Miss Manners has always suspected that he has also learned to pull away and say firmly, "Excuse me, I really must go" while making a dash for it.

DEAR MISS MANNERS: My husband believes that when setting a table, a soup/table spoon, dinner/place fork, and knife should always be provided, regardless of what will be served. I contend that only flatware appropriate for the meal being served need be provided. That is, if there will be no soup course, one need not include a soup spoon in the setting.

It seems to me that otherwise, there could theoretically be no end to which flatware should be provided, and surely we do not need cocktail forks at breakfast.

Can you please "set" us straight?

GENTLE READER: While Miss Manners is willing to overlook that pun, she cannot easily forgive your husband his mistake. His is a notion that has considerably blackened the reputation of the noble art of etiquette.

Laying out all the utensils -- and it is astonishing how many possibilities there are -- would turn the pleasure of mealtime into an unpleasant guessing game. Only the necessary utensils for each particular meal should be set out, and furthermore, they should be set on each side of the plate in the outside-to-inside order in which the corresponding courses will appear. We do not want to ruin anyone's digestion with trick settings.

:

Next up: More trusted advice from...

  • Is My Self-Care Selfish?
  • Transportable Tranquility
  • New Year, New Goal: To Be Happy
  • 7 Day Menu Planner for March 19, 2023
  • 7 Day Menu Planner for March 12, 2023
  • 7 Day Menu Planner for March 05, 2023
  • Taking a Life-Changing Risk
  • Reversing the Rise in Dangerous Driving
  • The Crazy World of Summer Camp Signups
UExpressLifeParentingHomePetsHealthAstrologyOdditiesA-Z
AboutContactSubmissionsTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
©2023 Andrews McMeel Universal