DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: Sorry to keep hitting up your inbox, but I wanted to offer an update that might save you a bit of work.
(Doctor’s note: too late!)
TL;DR, I happened to discuss the exact topic I wrote in about with my partner over the holidays, we had a great discussion, and I feel like the matter is more or less resolved and I no longer require advice. Though if you think it would be edifying for others to discuss it, feel free.��The process of writing in had already done a lot to organize my thoughts and the topic happened to come up. So, we just talked through it, and it really was that simple.��I wrote a lot about not being sure how much my concerns were valid and how much they were all in my head, specifically that I didn’t know if I *was* already seeing “my girlfriend’s polyamory in action.” And the short of the discussion is that that was exactly it: My girlfriend was already operating exactly how she wanted/planned to, she’s not really hunting for another partner, I’m her one and only primary partner, and that’s not really at risk of ever changing.��While I’m still a bit puzzled by how exactly my girlfriend’s version of polyamory works, I’m at least confident that what I’m seeing is what I’m getting. And I’m enjoying the relationship as it currently exists, so I don’t think there’s anything to worry about anymore.��I’m moving forward much more comfortable with the relationship and I no longer think I need to fear a far-off day when suddenly the entire relationship changes because she found someone new. Thankfully, it all had a happy ending!��-Goldilocks in Love
DEAR GOLDILOCKS IN LOVE: For the record, GIL: you did precisely what I would have advised, so hey, well done! I’m glad you resolved things before I even had a chance to respond.
I will say that your girlfriend’s version of polyamory isn’t really mysterious or strange; she’s aware of her capacity for attraction and love for more than one person at a time, and wants to make space for that possibility without endangering your relationship. Someone can be poly, even when they’re only dating – and only want to date – one person at present. She’s not actively looking for another partner or even necessarily wants one, but wants structures in place in the event that it does become an issue. While it can seem a little premature, having systems and structures in place are a good idea. As with many forms of preparedness, better to have things in place and not need them, than to need them and not have them.
The important thing about relationships in general and polyamory in particular is that relationships are supposed to serve the needs of the people in them, not vice versa. Your goal in a relationship is to shape one that matches the two of you, rather than to try to force yourself into a model that doesn’t fit. Much like a pair of shoes that don’t fit, you CAN try to force yourself into them and you may even be able to wear them around. However, they will pinch your feet, rub blisters on your heels and soles and hinder your ability to move around freely. If you insist on trying to make them work, regardless of how much it doesn’t fit, you run the risk of causing serious harm, and before long you won’t even be able to sit around comfortably, never mind actually walk or run.
The idea behind the various flavors of polyamory is to recognize that relationships aren’t one-size-fits-all, nor that any particular kind of relationship is inherently superior to another. Polyamory pushes against the norms of monogamy not because monogamy is bad and poly is more “evolved” or what-have-you, but the idea that monogamy works for everyone, that love is a limited resource or that some relationships are more “important” than others. Polyamory simply makes explicit what is often seen as implicit and unspoken in monogamy: that relationships require negotiation, clear and open communication, and understanding the needs of you and your partner (or partners) to work.
This is why I still suggest is that you should still do the readings I suggested. Even if you and your partner ultimately never exercise the option to see other people, the skills that the books teach and the vocabulary they provide apply to monogamous relationships just as much as they do to non-monogamous ones. Following those lessons and putting them in to practice will benefit your relationship, regardless of how many people become part of it. Doing the work now means that no matter what challenges come in the future for you and your sweetie, you’ll know what to do.
And as a wise man once said: knowing is half the battle.
I wish you both all the happiness going forward.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com