DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I am a 40-year-old man. I’ve had only one relationship in my life and it was a 5-year toxic and abusive mess. I was mentally abused, berated. While we did have sex, I was basically an automated sex toy and she refused to ever touch me outside of the body-to-body contact. So, I am not very well experienced.
I was bullied badly as a kid and was in high school at the height of abstinence teaching. They scared us out of having sex as they said doing so would give us disease and kill us. They brought in AIDS patients to scare us. It really messed me up for a long time. So, with all that, I ignored dating and women in my 20s.
I’ve been single now for 4 years. I’ve had no success on any apps. Occasional conversations that go nowhere. I’d say I get maybe one match a month or less. Recently I’ve had 0.
I’m invisible outside. I thought I hit it off with a barista at a local cafe. She gave me her number. But when I texted, it turned out it was not her number at all. I understand why she did that, but it still stung. She could have just said no. I stopped going after that due to humiliation.
I feel like I have to give up. I’m desperately trying not to give in to the “pill” discourse but I am seeing myself as a totally unlovable unattractive broken person. I don’t see why anyone would want to put up with this when there’s always better guys out there for them.
I appreciate any feedback here.
Trapped In An Empty Room
DEAR TRAPPED IN AN EMPTY ROOM: First and foremost, I’m so sorry for what you went through with your ex. Nobody deserves to be treated like that, and frankly, you’re well rid of her. I’m only sorry that you didn’t ditch her much, much sooner. It’s important that you understand that the way she treated you was heinous and undeserved, and holding it up as an example of how you are not well experienced is… well, honestly, it shouldn’t be held up as an example of anything other than abuse.
Now, having said that… I know it’s not what you’re going to want to hear, but I’m going to be honest here, AFTH: I think dating isn’t something you should be pursuing right now. From what you’ve described about your upbringing and your last (and thus far only) relationship, I don’t think you’re in a place where being out on the dating scene would be healthy or even advisable. If anything, I think actively pursuing a relationship or being on the dating scene might make things worse for you.
This has nothing to do with any sort of “pill” philosophy, your level of experience or your worth as a person and everything to do with the fact that I think you’re carrying around a lot of pain, scars and unhealed damage that needs to be dealt with first.
I don’t believe that people have to be perfect to date, or that they have to have passed X milestones and crossed Y thresholds in order to pursue a relationship, but I do believe that people have to be in good general working order. It’s as much about protecting yourself from future harm as it is about dealing with others or just being “ready” to date.
It’s a little like an older car; you may have to turn the key in the ignition a certain way to get the engine to catch, the upholstery may be torn and frayed and it may make noises when it shifts from 2nd to 3rdgear, but it will get you where you need to go reliably and safely. If, on the other hand, the brakes were prone to slipping or the engine would cut out randomly going uphill or at certain speeds, you would, rather understandably, not want to trust it on the open road. Doing so runs the risk of causing harm – whether to you or to other drivers on the road.
Based on what you’ve said – from the fear-mongering that kept you out of the scene in your 20s and the abuse you suffered at the hands of your ex – I think that there’s a lot more pain and unresolved harm going on than you may realize. While I absolutely understand your desire to find love and companionship and I completely empathize, I think that the ordinary stresses and frustrations of being on the dating scene are going to exacerbate things to an unhealthy degree.
Meeting people and putting yourself out there – whether on the apps or in person – requires a lot of vulnerability and a willingness to take on emotional risks, as well as being a headspace where you can reasonably gauge not just interest, but compatibility and safety, as well as having a grounded and accurate view of yourself and what you bring to the table. I think you are carrying around a lot more pain and baggage than you’ve realized, especially after the abuse you’ve endured. It’s very easy to end up with a warped and twisted view of yourself and how others see you after someone’s f--ked with your head and heart in such an egregious way.
And to be perfectly blunt, I would classify the abstinence only education you received as being in the same family of abuse, if not to the same degree. I find that sort of fear-focused “education” to be gross malpractice at best and frankly, I think it’s actively malignant. I can think of few messages more damaging and prone to setting people up for failure than “sex is dirty and wrong, degrades the person it’s done to and should only happen in the context of holy matrimony”.
I think the best thing you could possibly do for yourself is to take dating off the table for the moment and to focus on yourself. Specifically, I think the best possible thing you could do for yourself is to find a trauma-informed therapist, especially one who works with victims of sexual and relationship abuse, and talk with them about your struggles. If you don’t have a therapist or doctor who could give you a referral, the American Association of Sex Educators, Counselors and Therapists has a referral directory that can help you find a sex-positive therapist in your area.
I realize that it may sound like I’m saying that you’re too damaged to be love, but I promise you: I’m not and you are not. I’m saying that you have been hurt, that you’ve been lied to, and that you have been set up for failure. Being given inaccurate and often deliberately false information, taught to live in fear of sex and basic human relationships and then to have your first relationship be as toxic and abusive as the one you endured… it’s going to do a number on anyone’s sense of self-worth and desirability, never mind their connection to their own sexuality.
As much as I empathize and understand what you want right now, I honestly think that you would do much better to work with a therapist to at least talk about what you’ve been through and how it’s made you feel. It’s much, much harder to connect with someone, to gauge their interest and have a strong, mutually fulfilling and satisfying healthy relationship when you’ve been hurt in the ways you have been. I think the pain you’re carrying will not only get in the way of the people you would most love to connect with, but it twists the way you see yourself and relate to yourself. And I think that the potential harms that you would experience if you were to try to go out on the dating scene now vastly outweigh the benefits.
I know you feel like you’re behind in life. I know you feel like time must be running out or that your window for finding a relationship is closing, if it’s not closed already. I promise you: it absolutely is not. You are in no way, shape or form too late. There is time enough for healing and time enough for love. As hard as it can be, I think putting this search on pause is going to be the kindest but also bravest thing you can do right now, because you’ll be working on your relationship with yourself – your past, your present and most importantly – your future self.
I promise you: love will be ready and waiting for you when you are ready. But first, you need to heal.
All will be well.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com