DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I’m a 28-year-old woman and I’ve been in a polyamorous relationship with a man for about a year, and lately, I’m feeling more and more left out. My partner, “Nate,” is married, and his wife, “Sophie,” who also has a partner of her own, has known about and consented to our relationship from the beginning. I’ve had relationships where my partners and I weren’t exclusive before, but this is the first time I’ve had an actual emotional connection with someone who is romantically engaged with other people too.
At first, things felt open and honest. We’d all talk together, make sure everyone’s boundaries were respected, and check in about feelings. I’ve spent time with them together, stayed over at Nate’s when Sophie was out of town (with her knowledge and permission) and even spent time with Sophie one on one. I knew going in that Nate and Sophie were going to have history and live together and that would affect things, and that I was new to polyamory, so there would be growing pains. But over the past few months, it’s like I’ve become a side note in their lives. Plans get canceled at the last minute because something “came up” between them. When we’re together, he often talks about their shared routines or mentions inside jokes that he forgets I wasn’t part of, and I end up feeling like an outsider tagging along. I’ve tried to talk to him about it, but he insists everything is fine and that I’m “reading too much into it.” Sophie has been sympathetic, but I still feel like it’s sympathy for someone who doesn’t understand, rather than her being supportive.
I understand that his marriage will always come first to some extent — we talked about this going in, and that’s part of the structure we agreed on. But I can’t tell if what I’m feeling is just part of the natural imbalance in this kind of relationship, or if it’s a sign that I’m not being valued the way I should be.
Is it normal to feel this excluded in a poly relationship where one partner is married? And if it’s not, how do I even begin to address it without sounding jealous or demanding?
Signed, Feeling Like the Third Wheel
DEAR FEELING LIKE A THIRD WHEEL: This is a case of “the question you’re asking isn’t the question you think you’re asking”, and I think there’s an important one you’re not asking.
Let me start with something fairly obvious: there’s a lot of discourse about polyamory and the various forms it takes and how to manage it. There are folks who will insist that married people “can’t” be truly poly because of the inherent hierarchy, while other people will insist that “relationship anarchy” is unrealistic and unfeasible simply because you can’t expect every relationship to be equal when one is brand new and another has years of shared history, shared responsibilities and financial and social entanglements. There are folks who think kitchen-table poly (as in: everyone in the polycule lives together in a communal or shared space) is The Way while others think it’s better for everyone to have their own separate place. Get five poly people in a room and you’ll have six opinions on polyamory and all of them will conflict with the others in some fashion.
I mention this, simply to point out that there are many, many ways to have a polyamorous relationship, and the ins-and-outs of all of them will vary to one degree or another. This is important because it ties into the question you’re not asking.
So, to answer the question you think you’re asking: it’s not uncommon to feel like you’re being excluded. That doesn’t mean that it’s normal. Feeling excluded the way that you do isn’t inherent to the sort of relationship you have, but it does happen, because people are messy and concurrent relationships can be complicated and difficult to manage smoothly.
A couple who has been together for a period of time is, inevitably, going to have routines, habits, experiences, memories and inside jokes and things that, due to the linear nature of time, you will not have been part of. That necessarily doesn’t mean you’re being excluded; it just means that you weren’t there at the time when these were being formed.
Feeling excluded, however, is often a sign that there’s an imbalance somewhere. It’s one thing to not to get an inside joke. It’s another if you feel like you don’t have similar shared moments with your partner or partners.
Similarly, a couple who has been together is going to have shared responsibilities and responsibilities to one another that pre-date new partners, and the weight of that history may mean that – all things being equal – those take priority. That, however, is different from feeling like responsibilities to or with you always come second. Relationships �– whether monogamous or not – are a balancing act. While it may never be perfectly equitable, it should feel that things are roughly equal.
And it seems that for you, it doesn’t. This is why “is this normal” is the wrong question; you’re asking if you’re being unreasonable for feeling this way. And frankly, I don’t think you are. I think it may be worth your time to document things and see if this is a “feels like” vs. “objectively is” situation, but the fact that it is bothering you suggests that there may be a need going unmet here. It may be that you feel like you’re a secondary consideration, or that you and Nate haven’t had enough meaningful time to create those routines and jokes. It may mean that you feel like he’s not showing you the same level of love or consideration that he shows Sophie. Taking some time to dig into this might give you some answers, which will help shape how you should approach it.
I do think it’s fair to tell Nate that you feel like things are out of balance and that it feels as though Sophie is the default choice and you’re the secondary consideration. I’m also not thrilled that he’s told you that you’re “reading too much into it”. This might well be inartful phrasing, where he meant to say that he doesn’t consider you to be secondary or mean to make you feel excluded, but said it poorly. But I’m not necessarily inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt. You know him better than I do, so you would have to be the one to make that call.
However, I think the question you should be asking is “does this relationship model in general and this relationship specifically work for me?” That, I think, cuts a little closer to the real problem. I suspect that the biggest issue here is that this is your first poly relationship and you’re entering into it as the newcomer in a relationship that’s got years of history behind it already. That can have the effect of making you feel like a junior partner, rather than someone roughly equal… or at least, where equal importance feels achievable.
I suspect that if you weren’t dating someone who is sharing the lion’s share of his life – not just his emotional connection, but his physical presence and living space – with another person, you wouldn’t feel the same way. You came into this with the understanding that he was married and lived with his spouse, but that isn’t necessarily the same as having the experience to know how that would make you feel or whether it’s the kind of relationship you ultimately want.
I think another question that you should ask is why you chose this relationship – that is, what your motivation was for agreeing to this. Obviously, you care for Nate, and you feel that it’s possible to have romantic connections to more than one person at a time. But did you agree to this relationship because it was the only way you could have a relationship with him, specifically? If that’s the case… I wonder if maybe the problem is the relationship, rather than the relationship model.
I’ve seen people enter relationships where they were – as Dan Savage terms it – “poly under duress”, and that can be a difficult place to be in. Feeling like the only way to be with someone you care about is to accept feeling as though you’re only able to have some of their time or company is rough, and it can do a real number on your self-esteem. Making yourself miserable for what feels like scraps of attention is no way to live, even if you love the person. The feeling of only being given secondary consideration at best by someone you love, and feeling like someone else is their primary concern is a lot like being stabbed with tiny knives. The pain each of them causes individually may not be significant, but it compounds quickly and can become unbearable before you realize it.
So, I think before you talk to Nate, it will be worth your time to sit down and really think about this relationship. Is this relationship meeting your needs? Is this relationship model – dating a man with a live-in spouse – one that works for you and lets you feel loved and accepted? If the answer is “yes”, then I think having an Awkward Conversation, where you lay out how you feel a more balanced relationship would look, is the right move.
But if the answer is “no” to the either of those questions, then I think it may be time to classify this relationship as a learning experience, and one that may have been right for you when you started, but isn’t right for who you are now.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com