DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I have a question that’s not really about my relationship but about one I’ve been dragged into.
I work in a medium-to-small-sized department of a large corporation. Because we have a certain level of independence and separation from the rest of the company, we have our own culture of sorts – we’re not all close friends or know the intimate details of each other’s lives outside of the office or anything, but a lot of us are friendly and hang out together outside of work. I mention this because it will be relevant in a moment.
Recently, “James” was transferred to our department from another one. James is one of those guys who comes off a little cocky, a little too aggressively “cool” in some ways but otherwise seems like a decent guy – always friendly, supportive, a good worker and so on. He’s more social and more outgoing than a lot of my co-workers, so he can feel like a lot to most of the department – except for me. I was glad to have someone else to take the role of designated “department extrovert”, as well as potentially someone who wouldn’t head home after one post-work beer when I’m hoping to hang out longer. In fact, it was one of those post-work beers that caused the problem.
A few of us went to our local after work and invited James to join us. For reference, the bar we usually hang out at isn’t necessarily a meat market, but it’s a pretty social and active scene. I mention this because as our other co-workers were heading home, James and I noticed a couple of women from across the bar who seemed to be unaccompanied and also looking over at us. James decided that we should go talk to them and I, having been single for a while, thought this was a good idea.
This was all well and good. We were having a good conversation with the women, they clearly seemed to like us and “Marie”, the woman I was talking to, pulled me aside to ask about James – what’s he like, is he a good guy, that sort of thing. I answered honestly that he’d become one of the guys in my department that I hung out with regularly and while I hadn’t known him for all that long, yes, he was a pretty decent guy so far as I knew. I’m a little slow on the uptake sometimes, so I wasn’t sure what was going on and thought that maybe Marie was actually interested in James. She goes over to her friend “Cheryl”, pulls her aside for a second and they have a brief but apparently intense conversation. Then Marie comes back over to me and James and Cheryl leave together. Marie and I chat until she points out that Cheryl had the car, so would I be willing to give her a lift home. I agree, I drop Marie off and head back to my place. I get a text from James that said “thanks man, appreciate it”.
Next day at work, I ask James how things went and learn that yes, he and Cheryl hooked up back at her place, and he thanks me again and says “you can be my wingman any time…” because I guess he thinks we’re Maverick and Iceman or something. I’m happy enough to have helped a friend get laid, did my good deed for the week, maybe karma will smile on me now.
Fast forward two months later, my department has hit a pretty significant milestone and against all odds, we hit it early and somewhat under budget. Management is thrilled and arranges a private event for us to celebrate. A detail that will be relevant in a moment is that we’re all allowed to bring a plus-one. I’m there with Marie, and James arrives with a woman I’ve never seen before. She introduces herself as James’s girlfriend and over the course of the evening, we find that she and James have been together for two years now. This is new information to me. In all of our conversations, and his hooking up with Cheryl that night I told you about, I had every reason to think that James was single, though looking back at it I don’t know if he ever actually said he was or wasn’t. Maybe I missed it? I don’t know, but I’m pretty sure he didn’t, and at the time I wasn’t going to check with others for obvious reasons.
Regardless, Marie is visibly upset at both of us and makes an excuse to leave. I am too busy trying to manage Marie suddenly being mad at me to really grasp what has happened but over the course of the next couple of days involving very angry text chains and a lot of apologizing and swearing up and down I had no idea, I come to understand that James has been seeing Cheryl somewhat regularly and Cheryl has no idea he’s got a girlfriend. I finally convince Marie that I was ignorant of this, although she’s still upset, since she doesn’t see how I couldn’t have known that he had a girlfriend.
So, to make a long story short, I accidentally helped my friend cheat on his girlfriend and I’m not sure what to do here. Marie feels, and I have to agree, that I’m somewhat responsible since I vouched for him. She says Cheryl wouldn’t have gone home with him if I hadn’t. I don’t know how much I am to blame for this but I’m also not sure what to do about it. James and I haven’t talked, partially because work has been intense in the last couple of weeks, and partially because I don’t know what to say. I’m really pissed at James for making me complicit in his cheating and for being the cause of the mess in my relationship because of it. I need some advice on what to do now. Do I confront him over this? Do I go directly to his girlfriend and tell her? I assume she doesn’t know. How responsible am I and how do I fix things?
Help?
Accessory To The Crime
DEAR ACCESSORY TO THE CRIME: Ok, ATTC, under other circumstances, I’d say that you keep your nose out of this. Most of the time, when you (the generic “you”, not you specifically, ATTC) discover that someone you know may be cheating, the only smart move is to not get involved. You don’t know the circumstances of their relationship or what’s going on behind closed doors and most of the time, you can’t be 100% sure that what you’re seeing isn’t perfectly normal or innocent. Plus, depending on your relationship to the person cheating or being cheated on, getting involved usually ends up creating unnecessary drama and can result in someone metaphorically shooting the messenger.
Of course, that all goes out the window when you were a critical part of said cheating. This isn’t just you stumbling across incriminating information or seeing someone having some sort of intimate moment with another person who isn’t their partner. You and James were out having a guy’s night and you helped facilitate his going home with Cheryl. That means you’re directly involved in this affair.
But please notice very carefully that I said “involved”, not “complicit”. I doubt that he’s such a cartoon villain that he planned this deliberately and with malice aforethought, but even under the most generous interpretation of events, he allowed you to believe something that wasn’t true and used that when it was convenient for him. That is a f--ked-up thing to do to someone, and doubly so to a friend and co-worker.
By the same token, I think Marie is upset – quite reasonably – because of how her friend’s been hurt and some of that is splashing back on you. That part isn’t necessarily fair. It’s understandable – we’re rarely perfectly rational when someone’s f--ked over our friends and we’re angry about it – but not fair.
Yes, you may have been a key factor in that fatal instant where things could’ve gone either way – he goes home with Cheryl or he goes home alone – but you were acting in good faith. You, not unreasonably, assumed that James was single and free to hook up with whomever he chose. James, on the other hand, deliberately deceived you. He may not have said he was in a long-term and apparently monogamous relationship, but he sure as hell allowed you to believe it. At the very least, this wasn’t just lying by omission, he was actively misleading you. Worse, he put you in a position where you ended up misleading two other people, which is extremely not cool. You were a victim of his s--tty behavior and choices, not an accomplice. Certainly not a witting one.
(I hesitate to call it “lying”, since you sincerely believed you were telling the truth, and James certainly never gave you reason to think otherwise.)
So, if I’m being honest here: while you were involved in Cheryl being hurt by all of this, I don’t think you were at fault here. This is entirely James’s doing; he lied to Cheryl, he’s presumably lying to his girlfriend and he seems to be blithely unaware – or unconcerned – about the position this has put you in and what it’s done to your relationship with Marie.
Should you have known? How could you have? Yes, I suppose an argument could be made that maybe you could have inquired about whether James was actually single or not, but frankly that’s more a matter of hindsight being 20/20 rather than a failure on your part. It’s not unreasonable to assume that James would’ve mentioned the existence of a girlfriend at some point and his behavior that night would lead most folks to think otherwise. I think someone has to be looking very hard for reasons to be upset at you if they were going to blame you for not pointedly asking “hey, you’re not about to cheat on a partner I don’t know about, are you?”
So what do you do about this? First, I think it would be worth apologizing to Cheryl. Yeah, you’re not at fault here – again, you had no idea and no reasonable way of knowing �– but it happened and you were involved. I think it’s worth telling her that you’re sorry, that James had lied to you too and you would never have been party to this if you’d known. Don’t make the apology about you – James lied to you both, but she’s the more injured party here – but do acknowledge her pain and your part in it.
Next, I’d say that you should confront James and tell him, to his face, that what he did was f--ked up and he needs to keep his distance from you from now on. Make it clear: you wouldn’t have been a part of this if you’d known that he had a girlfriend, and you are incredibly pissed at how his bulls--t move meant that you were involved in hurting people, and it has caused problems in your relationship.
I’d also suggest that maybe you should talk to your direct report and mention that you and James aren’t going to be able to work together. You don’t have to say why, nor do you have to see about transferring out of the department or trying to get James transferred. Life will be a lot easier and considerably more peaceful for everyone if you two don’t get thrown together on projects after he’s screwed you like this.
What I wouldn’t suggest is talking to his girlfriend. For one thing, you have no idea what she knows or doesn’t know. Maybe she knows that Cheryl exists but not the dirty details. Maybe she’s completely ignorant of all of this; the last thing you want is to not only have facilitated his cheating but also be the one who delivers the news to the person he cheated on. You’re already far too involved in this, which is the entire problem. Going to her – someone, I must stress, you don’t actually know – is only going to entrench you even deeper in this mess and you neither want nor need that.
Now, it’s your call as to whether you mention any of this to your coworkers. If James starts cozying up to one of them, they may be at risk of finding themselves in the same position you were. But on the other hand, you’re not the spirit of vengeance nor the swift hand of karmic retribution; you’re a guy who got dragooned into this bulls--t against his will. Better to wall yourself off from James’s drama and bulls--t behavior than to continue to be a character in this narrative.
It sucks you got pulled into this, and I hope Marie realizes that your involvement was not by choice. Tell James to get f--ked and put as much distance between you as you can.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com