DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I pen this missive from the very depths of what can only be described as a romantic abyss, a chasm so deep and echoing with loneliness that even my own sighs sound like mournful whale song. I am a man teetering on the precipice of… well, continued celibacy, unless your wisdom can illuminate a path through my particularly thorny thicket of filial piety and forbidden desires.
You see, I am a Chinese man, and I share my abode – nay, my very existence – with a creature of legend, a force of nature, the indomitable Tiger Mother. She is, in her own way, magnificent: a whirlwind of ambition (for me, primarily), discipline (again, for me), and a traditional conservatism so profound it makes ancient scrolls look like radical manifestos. Her love for me is undeniable, expressed primarily through relentless pressure to excel academically and professionally. Socializing? A frivolous distraction. Dating? Anathema, a siren song luring me away from the glorious shores of a PhD and a six-figure salary.
Every fiber of her being, every carefully chosen word, every disapproving glance when I so much as look at my phone for too long, screams “Study! Work! Succeed! Love is for later, much later, probably after you’ve cured a major disease and won a Nobel Prize, and even then, I’ll pick her.” Moving out, you ask? Ha! The very suggestion would likely cause her to spontaneously combust, or worse, unleash a lecture series on the sacred duty of a son that would span several lunar cycles. I am, for all intents and purposes, a well-educated, gainfully employed prisoner in a gilded cage of familial expectation.
And yet, a traitorous heart beats within this dutiful chest. It yearns! It longs! Not for grand, sweeping romance just yet (though one can dream, can’t one?), but for something… simpler. A coffee. A shared laugh. The flutter of nerves before a casual date. The simple, human experience of getting to know someone, perhaps even holding a hand without it immediately triggering a mental calculation of wedding banquet costs. I wish to date casually, to dip a toe into the waters of modern romance, to feel, for a fleeting moment, like a normal young man.
But here, my dear sage, is where my pathetic plight curdles into a truly Sisyphean comedy of errors. To pursue even the most innocent liaison, I must operate with the stealth and cunning of a covert operative. Every text message is a coded transmission, every potential outing a meticulously planned black-ops mission, conducted far from the all-seeing eye of my maternal warden.
And the women? Ah, the women! The ones I find myself drawn to, the ones who might understand the delicate cultural tightrope I walk, are often, by some cruel cosmic joke, in the exact same predicament. They too reside under the watchful gaze of their own Tiger Parents. And their parents, bless their traditional hearts, have a system. Oh, do they have a system. Before their precious daughters can even think about sharing a bubble tea with a suitor, said suitor (that’s me, in this tragicomedy) must undergo a rigorous parental approval process. This isn’t a casual meet-and-greet; it’s an interrogation, a background check, a dynastic compatibility assessment rolled into one terrifying tea ceremony.
And here’s the kicker, the real twist of the knife in my already bleeding romantic aspirations: if, by some miracle, I pass this parental gauntlet, if I am deemed “suitable,” the casual dating dream evaporates like morning mist. Parental approval automatically catapults the relationship into SERIOUS territory. We are now, by unspoken decree, monogamous. We are, by implicit understanding, on the slow but inexorable march towards marriage. There is no “let’s just see where this goes.” It goes towards a red envelope filled with wedding money, and quickly.
So, you see my dilemma? To date casually, I must deceive my mother. To date the women I’m interested in casually, I must also help them deceive their parents. We become co-conspirators in a multi-layered charade of clandestine coffee dates and whispered phone calls, all while pretending to our respective parental units that our social lives are as barren as the Gobi Desert. It’s exhausting! It’s unsustainable! It makes the very idea of a “casual date” feel like attempting to juggle flaming torches while riding a unicycle on a high wire, with both sets of parents holding the safety net hostage.
What am I to do? How does one navigate this minefield of maternal expectation and potential-in-law scrutiny, all for the sake of a simple, uncomplicated date? Is there a secret handshake for culturally-constricted Casanovas? Are there underground support groups?
My hope, a tiny, flickering ember in the vast darkness of my romantic despair, rests with you. Please, shed some light. Tell me there’s a way. Tell me I’m not doomed to a life of academic achievement and utter, soul-crushing loneliness, punctuated only by the occasional, terrifyingly high-stakes covert operation for a cup of tea.
With a heart heavy with unspent affection and a schedule full of secret plotting,
Yours in desperate hope,
Tiger Baby (and my ever-watchful mother, who probably already knows I’m writing this somehow).
DEAR TIGER BABY: Right, I guess we get to do this again. TB, I understand that you’re trying to be clever and expressive, but when your writing makes you sound like you’re trying to channel Oscar Wilde and Sephiroth, it ends up working against you. At best, the florid prose gets in the way of what you’re trying to actually ask and at worst it makes you come across as someone who thinks this is a substitute for having a personality.
I realize I’m the God-Emperor of “Why use one word when five will do”, but this ultimately ends up bloating your letter to the point where it gets hard to separate your actual issue from the rhetorical flourishes. You don’t need to be Hemingway, but you don’t need to be Abelard writing letters to Heloise either.
With that in mind: I actually had to read your letter multiple times because there’s a few important data points that I’m just not seeing here. The first is very simple: how old are you and the women you’re trying to date? Context clues would suggest that you’re at least over 18, which is makes you a legal adult in most countries, so your mother would hold little legal sway over your choices.
The second is: how much actual leverage does your mother have over you? I don’t mean parental disapproval or cultural pressure – we’ll get to that in a moment. I mean actual, significant means that she could use to ensure and enforce your obedience. From the sounds of things, you’re not in college and you’re employed full-time and you live at home. It doesn’t sound as though your mom is continuing to pay the tuition fees for your education or that you are contractually indebted to her in some way (inter-family loans to cover major purchases or tuition and so-on). From a strictly pragmatic perspective, unless you’ve left something relevant and important out, this is ultimately about emotional control, not financial. You’re not at risk of having to drop out of college or being homeless and destitute if you risk your mother’s displeasure.
So, assuming I’m correct about these, your mother has very little actual leverage over you. The biggest impediment to dating the way you would want to is, well, you.
Now, I get the social pressure and expectation. I’m a middle-aged white dude, so it’s easy for me to say “so what’s the problem,” especially since my personal view is that tradition is just peer pressure from dead people. I don’t have the same cultural upbringing, haven’t lived my life with that as being part of the ocean I swim in, and I’m not going to have the same reaction to that pressure. My advice should be taken with all appropriate amounts of salt with that in mind.
But while I may not grok the level of pressure and tradition you’re dealing with, I feel like (and hope that) I’m at least comprehending it. Socialization is a motherf--ker and it can be really hard to push back against social norms and expectations that you’ve been raised in all your life. Doubly so if you live in a community where everyone lives under similar expectations and there’s not just familial but societal pressure to conform. Breaking with those norms means risking social opprobrium and issues within your community. That s--t is hard to shake.
However, it is also all that’s standing between the life you want and the life you feel like you “have” to lead. You’re going to have to decide which is more important to you – having the freedom to date who you want, have the kinds of relationships you want to have and generally be in control of your own destiny – or acceding to your mother’s wishes.
So, you basically have three choices here. One is to keep your head down, play the dutiful son and wait until your mom passes away so that you can finally live how you want. The second is to try to date the way that Cold War era spies used to have to sneak in and out of East Berlin to see their contacts and cut-outs. The third is to stop fearing parental disapproval and make your mother fear your disapproval.
Now, are there ways you could date on the down-low? Sure… as long as you don’t mind having to be relentlessly paranoid while also relying on third parties to help run cover for you. You and your dates could communicate exclusively on Signal or apps that automatically delete messages after reading them. Seeing as your mother has full access to your phone, you’d have to use the Android or iOS “Hide App” feature to keep her off your back. You’d also need confederates to help at least create the illusion of group outings with friends that would allow you to sneak away and meet up with your sweetie and hope that your friends are good at keeping their stories straight. You also have to hope that anyone you date, even casually, is equally as conscious and dedicated to their privacy and security, as are your (and their) co-conspirators. As Leverage has taught us again and again: people are the weak point in every security system. The more people involved in the conspiracy, the less secret it becomes and the more likely it’ll be revealed.
But hey, at least then you could see just how long your relationships could last under the strain of never knowing who you can trust with your secrets and who is likely to blab – deliberately or by accident or through poor social op-sec – and never being comfortable being seen in public with your snugglebunny in case someone spots you together and word gets back anyway.
(You may want to ask some queer friends with homophobic or transphobic parents how much ‘fun’ that can be, incidentally. Especially now that the US government is ready to shove every LGBTQ+ person back into the closet or else.)
Or you can decide that you’re a grown-ass adult and while the lectures may be excoriating and the disapproval can sting… you don’t actually have to listen. To quote Da Share Zone: just walk out. You can leave. You can, in fact, not wait for the lecture to finish. You are able to turn on your heel in mid-sentence and walk away, hang up the phone without waiting for her to so much as pause for breath or otherwise not give her any more of your time and attention in this matter than you want. Will she combust and yell about the sting of an ungrateful child? OK… and? A temper tantrum for not getting one’s way is still a temper tantrum, even when the person throwing it is in their 40s, 50s or older, and you don’t reward a temper tantrum by giving the person what they want.
Will it suck for a bit? Sure. You love your mother, even if she’s a major pain in your ass and living barricade to your social life. Her blowing up at you and being both hurt and angry are going to sting, possibly quite a lot. You don’t want to disappoint her or hurt her and that’s entirely understandable.��But the point of being a parent is to one day stop being a parent. There comes a point where the kids are going to leave home and live their own lives; it’s just a matter of when and under what circumstances. What your mom’s doing is continuing to treat you as a child, regardless of your age. Even when it’s coming from a place of wanting what she thinks is the best for you and wanting you to succeed, it’s still stifling.
Your presence in her life is optional and conditional, and you are the only person who gets to decide what those conditions are. You can make it clear that while you love her and care for her, you’re not going to be present as long as she treats you like a child or a project to manage. She can treat you like an adult or she can kick rocks. And “I’ll treat you like an adult when you act like one” or similar statements puts her squarely in “kick rocks” territory.
And to be clear: it’s entirely possible that this will mean not seeing your mother for a long time. There’re folks who could medal in grudge-holding for the Olympics. They’re ones who have resolved that they’ll heal in Hell. But there is a point in every estranged parent’s life where they have to decide whether they love their kids more than they want to hold onto whatever moral victory they think they have. They may never admit that they were wrong… but they can at least bend enough to put it aside in the name of actually having a relationship with their children. Hopefully, if you take this route, your mother would be one of those, and who would get there sooner rather than later.
But like I said: it’s ultimately going to come down to choices. And yes, those choices will have consequences; every choice does. You just have to decide whether those potential consequences and what they bring with them are a price you’re willing to pay.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com