DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I’ve been seeing this amazing woman, “Maria” for the over a year now, and honestly, this is probably the best relationship I’ve been in. We click on every level I could want from a girlfriend or wife. She’s quite honestly the whole package. She’s smart, ambitious, creative, caring, stubborn as the day is long when it’s called for. I watched with awe as she went full mama-bear over the way the school seriously mishandled an issue with her son. I would crawl over broken glass for the privilege of doing her laundry. Because we’ve been together for this long and because I honestly think I’ve got something real and lasting with Maria, we’ve reached the stage where she finally introduced me to her son. He’s a great kid. Smart like his mom, imaginative, loves building things. He’s a little shy, but he and I are getting along well.
Advertisement
Here’s the thing: I knew that she was a single mom from the beginning. It never bothered me. But now that we’re moving into more serious territory and this is clearly more than a short-term thing, some of my friends have started making comments. When we were starting to date, nobody really said anything. Now, I’m noticing their attitudes change. At first, it was just the occasional joke. Stuff like, “So when’s your next PTA meeting?” or “Ready to trade your balls in for a minivan?” Standard ball-busting stuff on the surface, maybe, but now that I’m getting serious about her, the tone of the jokes have started changing for the worse.
Now they’re outright telling me I’m making a mistake. That I’m a fool for “raising another man’s kid,” that I’ll “never come first,” and that women like her are just looking for substitute dads, that I won’t be able to love a child that’s not biologically mine. Some of them even send me clips of these internet “alpha male” types who talk about how men should avoid single mothers at all costs, how we’re being conned or being taken advantage of.
The worst part is, it’s making me question whether I’m making a bad decision here. Not about whether I really care about Maria and her son, but if I’m actually father material. I care deeply about Maria, and I think the world of her son. But now I wonder if I’m ready to be a father and what will happen if Maria and I have a child together in addition to her son? Will I unconsciously favor my child over him? And what if my friends are right, and I’m signing up for a life that will always come second? I also worry that maybe I’d end up hurting her son or doing wrong by him somehow, even unintentionally and I’d never want that.
I know this is irrational thinking and I hate that these thoughts are even in my head, because this relationship has been nothing but healthy, supportive, and full of joy. I don’t want to let toxic noise from the outside world sabotage something real. But I also don’t want to walk blindly into something I’m not emotionally ready for.
How do I know if I’m truly cut out for this? And how do I deal with friends who seem more interested in mocking my relationship than supporting it?
Sincerely,
Is This Shirt Made of Father Material?
DEAR IS THIS SHIRT MADE OF FATHER MATERIAL: There’s one surefire way to solve your problem, ITSMFM: you need a better class of friends, so you should dump this crew and trade up.
I’m being serious here. I don’t know if you’re dealing with a bunch of Peter Pan wanna-bes who never actually grew up or folks who’ve been huffing the fumes from a bunch of right-wing, men’s rights cesspools until it cooked their brains or what, but these aren’t your friends. They’re a bunch of people you’ve known for a while and there’s a difference.
Friends are people who love and support you and want the best for you. If there were legitimate reasons to worry – Maria behaved in questionable ways, you had a habit of leaping into relationships before you were ready, you were someone who didn’t have the maturity or sense of responsibility to manage your own life, never mind helping to raise a child… yeah, there might be cause for friends to say “hey, have you thought this through? Are you sure you’re ready for this level of responsibility?” They’d be giving you a reality check and asking you to put some real thought into this.
Instead, they’re coming at you with the sort of claims that a z-tier Joe Rogan guest would be ashamed to make and telling you that the woman you’ve been dating for over a year now is just using you to find a dad for her son. That doesn’t sound like friends or compatriots or people who want what’s best for you. That sounds like a bunch of people who’ve never had a thought that didn’t come pre-chewed by a bunch of people who sell drop-shipped dick pills, crypto scams, and courses how to use abuse tactics to keep women in line. The fact that they’re telling you that you can’t – not just won’t, but can’t love a child because you’re not biologically related to them tells me that they know next to nothing about love or parenting. I wouldn’t be relying on these guys to pick a movie, never mind relationship advice.
Hell, I don’t think I’d trust their opinions on cheese.
I’m sure that, at some point, your friendship with them must have been rewarding in some way. It sure as hell sounds like those days are long gone, and it’s kind of a question mark in my brain as to why they’re still around.
So let me ask you a serious question: you talk about standard ball-busting behavior, but when is the last time any of these guys have been even remotely supportive of you? I don’t mean in the sense of “bought you a beer when you had a long day” – though that’s up in the air too. I mean “when is the last time they’ve done something or said something that made a positive and meaningful impact in your life?” Have they ever encouraged you to pursue a dream that you had put on hold? Have they ever rallied around you when things were bad and you were in a low point?
I mean, sure, a lot of guys have friendships with a degree of brotherly antagonism and s--t-talk. But could you go to these guys – either one-on-one or as a group and admit to being scared or confused and needing support? If you had a legitimate problem – something that couldn’t be ‘solved’ with jocularity and booze – could you go to them and expect real or meaningful support? Would they have your back and cheer you on if you were going to take a leap of faith in your career, especially if it meant something like moving away? Would they be ready to rally around you if you had a devastating loss and needed help? Would they even be people you could turn to if you needed someone to dog-sit while you were out of town?
Or are these the kinds of friends where you might go to the bar to see the game with, but you couldn’t rely on if you needed real help?
Because it sounds to me like this is a bunch of people who would s--t-talk someone for trying to get sober and keep insisting that one beer never hurt anyone… even knowing that it would never stop at one beer.
There’re a lot of times when the people in our lives are only there because of inertia and/or longevity; they’re part of our social circle because we’ve known them for so long that it seems like we have to keep them around. I promise you: you absolutely don’t. If someone has become a genuine net-negative in your life, someone who doesn’t just bring out the worst in you but actively drags you backwards or pulls you down like a millstone around your neck? That’s someone who you can cut out of your life without worry… even if they’ve been in it for a while.
And it sure as s--t sounds like your friends have taken on that role with glee. So I think you should match their energy by cutting them loose with equal enthusiasm.
I’m going to be honest: I focus on the issue of your friends because that sounds like the real problem here. If it hadn’t been for them acting like all the most-divorced-man energy in your state wished really hard and became a real boy, I doubt you’d be having any question about your feelings for Maria or caring for her son. And while I know that the plural of anecdote isn’t “data”: I have known people personally who have been in relationships with single mothers, who have married single mothers and had children with them… and quite frankly I have never seen more devoted and supportive dads to all of their children. Whether by biology or by marriage, their boys are their boys and that’s the end of the story.
There are real things to be concerned about when it comes to having a serious relationship with a single mother. This isn’t one of them. Not for you, not for these circumstances and not for this relationship with Maria or her son.
Here’s the other thing to keep in mind: nobody knows for sure whether they’re ready to be parents. Even people who’ve read all the books, took all the courses, did all the prep-work they could… they worry about if they’re ready. And in a real way, they can’t be, because as the saying goes: man plans and the gods laugh. Nothing ever goes to plan, especially where kids are involved. But the people who make the best parents are the ones who resolve that they’re going to do the best job they possibly can, no matter what happens. The ones who’ve prioritized loving and raising their kids more than “being ready” or having their lives planned out.
Now, I do want to make a cautionary note: it sounds like you only just met her son. That’s a huge step in and of itself. Being in her son’s life on a regular basis is going to be a big change to his life. I think you should give more time before you take the next one. He’s going to need some time to adjust and you are going to need time to find your place in the family dynamic.
And that part is important. You don’t mention, for example, whether his father’s still in the picture and if so, under what circumstances. You don’t mention whether Maria is co-parenting with her son’s father, what her relationship is with his father, what her son’s relationship is with his father… these are all important things to take into consideration. Even under the best of circumstances, where everyone’s at least in a happy, respectful and supportive relationship, it takes time to merge into the dynamic without unnecessary disruption or confusion.
Don’t get me wrong: I think you’re doing a great job so far, and it sounds like you’re with a great woman. I also think a little apprehension and worry, especially for her son’s well-being says a lot about you. If you weren’t worried that you might make things worse for him… well, I’d be more concerned. But from the sounds of it, your heart and your head are in the right place.
As far as your relationship with Maria goes, I think the best thing you can do is give it time. You’ve reached a significant stage with them; now you need to let things settle a bit and the three (or four) of you will find your new status quo before it’ll be time for the next step.
But your friends? I think they’re surplus to requirements at best, an active anchor at worst. It sounds like you grew up and they just grew older. It’s time to cut them loose and find better ones.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com