DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I am a girl and I’m facing a bit of a problem with my relationship. I have a boyfriend and I also have a guy who has a crush on me. Recently the boy with a crush told me that my boyfriend has approached a friend and he also told her that he’s not dating with someone. Should I trust my crush or my boyfriend? What if he’s telling me the truth. I’m really confused.
Who Do You Trust?
DEAR WHO DO YOU TRUST: I really wish you’d lead with how old you are, WDYT, because you sound very young. Granted, I’ve seen plenty of people in their 30s and 40s who treat interpersonal relationships like intrigue in the Imperial Court, complete with spreading rumors to discredit their rivals and whisper campaigns to win the Empress’ favor, but this reads like some high-school drama to me.
But hey, if nothing else, it’ll be a good life lesson for you going forward.
Now speaking entirely for myself: as a general rule, I’m more inclined to believe your boyfriend over the guy with the crush. There’s an agenda there, and I’ve dealt with too many people who thought that they should go telling tales when they thought they had dirt on a rival.
But that’s just me. I’m bringing my own baggage and beliefs to the table here and that influences my judgement. You actually know these guys, so you’re in a much better place to determine what’s going on and who’s on the up and up or not.
Here’s what you want to do: you want to reign in any knee-jerk reactions you may have one way or the other. Right off the bat, it’s very easy to make a snap judgement in either direction, for reasons that seem completely rational and sensible on the surface.
For example: the dude with a crush on you might have a vested interest in lying to you. You get angry at your boyfriend, you break up and hey, here comes Studly Good Night to come comfort you in your time of woe. Or your boyfriend could well be the sort of cad who’ll lie about whether he’s seeing someone or even play word games – he didn’t say he wasn’t seeing someone, so it’s not his fault if a woman took him at his word.
If you have any sort of insecurities or anxieties, especially regarding your relationship, those will play into this as well. If you already worry that you’re not “good enough” for your boyfriend or feel worried that he’ll find someone “better”, then you’re much more likely to believe someone who brings you bad news that lines up with what you’re already afraid of. But on the other hand, if you’re already annoyed or have issues with the guy who has a crush on you, you may be willing to dismiss him out of hand when he’d be telling you the absolute truth.
But this also falls into the trap of binary thinking: that one of them must be telling the truth and one must be lying. It could well be a third option: they’re both telling the truth…as they see it. Your beau with a crush could well have seen an otherwise innocent and innocuous interaction between your boyfriend and some other woman and misunderstood or misinterpreted what was actually happening… so while he may have hopes that bringing you this bad news may work out for him, he’s bringing you this information in good faith… so far as he knows, anyway.
What you want to do is to do your best to look at this as dispassionately as possible, based on what you know about your boyfriend and about the guy with a crush on you. Does your boyfriend have a track record of trying to be a player? Does he have a tendency to lie to you or to others? With all you know about him, is it genuinely plausible that he’d act like this? Has he ever behaved in a way to make you doubt his sincerity or fidelity? Has he cheated before, either on you or on previous partners? Have you ever had a reason not to trust him?
Similarly, what about the guy with a crush. Are you sure he is actually trustworthy? Have all of his behaviors been entirely on the up and up, or has he tried weird manipulative bulls--t before? Is he, for example, the sort of person who’d pull Nice Guy antics – trying to be your friend in hopes that he could backdoor his way into a relationship with you? Does he seem to be keeping track of all the things he’s done as reasons why you should pay him back with dates or sex? Is he someone who, through his actions, proven to be trustworthy and reliable?
Just as importantly, is he someone whose judgement can be trusted? Even allowing for the fact that he is not an impartial observer, has he shown – again, through his actions and behavior – that he’s actually a good judge of character or who can read a potentially complex situation accurately? Or is he more likely to make a rush to judgement, especially if doing so might bring him more firmly into your favor?
And while we’re at it… does he actually name names? Is this a specific person that you could go and talk to, or is it just some nebulous “other girl” who may or may not exist.
If you look into this as impartially and objectively as you can, with as much awareness of your own biases, fears and inclinations to believe one thing over another, what seems the most plausible answer to you?
If you have actual reason to not trust your boyfriend – not just out of anxiety but things he’s done that have set off your Spidey-sense – then you may want to confront him over this. But if that doesn’t sound even vaguely like something he’d do? I’d hold off on the accusations.
And if the guy with a crush is someone who isn’t a stand up guy who just happens to be infatuated with you? Well… I think his agenda is a little too obvious for him to be trusted without more than just his word on the matter.
Do your best with what you know to be true, and then let that be your guide.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com