DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I’ve got a problem. I’m 16, a high-school sophomore, and I’m really interested in a girl in my class, and I really need some advice on how to get her to notice me. Here’s the thing tho: she’s already got a boyfriend. I know it sounds sketchy, but hear me out.
So, this girl, let’s call her Emily, is incredibly cool. She’s got this killer sense of humor and she’s crazy smart and always says things that make me laugh. And I’m going to be honest: she’s hot too. I spend a lot of time on her Insta and Snapchat where she’s always posting pics of herself and her friends and I just can’t stop checking her out. But it’s not all shallow, I promise. The more I get to know her, the more I think we’d be perfect together. We’re both into the same music, movies, and even some low-key nerdy stuff. It’s kinda wild how much we have in common.
The problem is Emily’s current BF. Dude’s a f--king idiot and so not her type. He’s like every jock ever who thinks he’s just king s--t because he plays a stupid game (JV, even, not the top team), and it’s obvious he doesn’t appreciate Emily the way she deserves. He’s always flirting with other girls – I’ve caught him creeping on other girls’ pics with his finsta – and doesn’t seem to care about her feelings. It pisses me off just thinking about it.
Now, I ain’t gonna lie, I’m not exactly the most popular guy in school or anything, but I know I’d treat her way better than jackass jerk jock, you know? I’d actually listen to her, be there for her, and just make her feel special, all that. But, like, how do I even begin to show her that when she’s all wrapped up in her current relationship?
Doc, can you give me some tips on how to catch Emily’s eye without coming off as a total creep? I don’t wanna be that guy, but I know we’d be awesome together. Is there a way to squeeze him out, maybe help her realize he’s a tool and just help her see what she could have with me?
Thanks a bunch, man. Looking forward to your advice!
I’m Mr. Right Here
DEAR I’M MR. RIGHT HERE: Letters like this make me glad I’m not a teenager anymore. The constant confusion, self-inflicted drama and feeling all those feelings without any goddamn clue how to handle them…
OK IMRH, let’s dispense with this right off the bat: it’s cool that you think you’re her perfect guy and all, but you know who actually gets to decide who’s right for her?
That’d be Emily.
Here’s the thing: you’re falling for the classic “nice guy/girls-like-assholes” fallacy, where “asshole” really means “dude as what has what I want”. You’re working from limited information about Emily and SuperJock’s relationship – you’re only seeing a fraction of a fraction of their time together, drawing conclusions from facts not in evidence and letting your crush on Emily (and jealousy of her boyfriend) fill in the blanks. You have no idea what the two of them are like when you’re not around, what sort of things they do together or what interests they share, or how he actually treats her when you aren’t around to see. You’re basing your idea that he doesn’t or can’t like or respect her like you do on wishful thinking and fantasy, not reality. For all you know, he’s into the same things she is, or that she’s way more into his interests than in the ones you supposedly share. You’re seeing a very limited slice of his life and hers, and what you see at school is never going to be the full picture. Neither, for that matter, is what either of them share over social media; social media is always going to be a highly-curated, deceptive view of someone.
Neither, for that matter, do you know what their relationship is like. You say you’ve caught him creeping on other girls’ Instagram pics… but do you know whether Emily is unaware of this? Since you don’t indicate that you and Emily are friends or that you actually talk all that often, you have no way of knowing what they’re up to behind closed doors. She could well be aware that her boyfriend’s looking at other girls’ pics and doesn’t care. And if she is ignorant of it… well, it’s not your relationship and not your business. Sticking your nose in, especially when you’re not already friends to begin with, is just you trying to justify breaking them up so that you can swoop in and take her for yourself.
But let’s say you do reveal that he’s got a wandering eye. Do you think that she’s going to thank you? Do you think that she’s going to be grateful to you if the two of them break up? And – importantly – do you really think that after she has a tumultuous break up that she’s just going to be open to anyone rolling up and saying “you ditched the zero now get with the hero?”
If they do break up – whether you’re involved or not – you’re in no way guaranteed a chance with her. Especially if you don’t have a pre-existing relationship already. You could well engineer their break up – or see it happen organically – and then see her go out with someone else entirely, while still being unaware that you’re interested. She may even go out with another jock.
And here’s another thing to consider: if you care about her and want what’s best for her, why are you not allowing her to decide what’s best? If you respect her the way you say, then you want to respect her choices, too. Declaring that you know better than she does is presumptive at best, out and out insulting at worst.
But let’s say you’re right and you’re objectively the best possible person she could date at your school. The way you prove this is by demonstrating it, not just stating it loudly. Anybody can say “I’m the best, you should be with me,” but that means nothing if you can’t actually back it up. So if you want her to see you as a possible match, you have to actually be living those qualities. And not in some flashy, show-off-y “look at me” way. That’s going to be come off as way too try-hard and be more likely to turn her off. Living your best life and being your best self is going to be a better way of demonstrating your superior qualities.
But as I’m often saying: you can’t Be Your Best Self at someone. You have to just… live your life and hope that other people pick up on it. Maybe embracing your best self will raise your profile and she’ll notice you, but if you focus just on getting noticed, you’re not going to get as far. After all, getting noticed or getting attention is easy. S--t on the floor in the cafeteria and everyone is going to notice and pay attention.
Instead, my recommendation is to make the most of your high-school years, without making Emily the focus. Volunteer around school, join some clubs, join a team or band or debate, s--t maybe even play some sports. Use this time to explore who you are as a person, find the things you’re good at or interested in and pursue those. They may lead to her noticing you… or they may not. But they’ll make your life better overall, and it’ll get you ready for life after high-school… which is far more important.
Because here’s the hard truth, IMRH: this is a high-school crush, and the vast, vast majority of high-school relationships don’t last past graduation. Many don’t last between grades. Despite what people tell you, high-school isn’t the best or most important time of your life, and despite how pop-culture makes it seem, these relationships are going to be much more fleeting than you realize. These years are essentially training for the next stage of your life, whether that’s college, learning a trade or some other choice.
Your feelings for Emily are intense, sure, but that’s because you’re young. I would be willing to bet you $20 cash that by your senior year, you’ll have moved on from her and fallen for someone else. And even if not, after graduation, you will almost certainly move on.
So spend less time worrying about who Emily is dating and focus instead on figuring out who you are, what makes you tick and what you can do to live your best life. Take full advantage of what your school has to offer and the opportunities presented to you. Make a point of being more social, cultivating your social skills, making more friends, and you may find yourself in a “king of the school” role too – different from Captain Got-Yo-Girl, sure, but still popular or important. Maybe Emily will notice. Maybe you’ll meet someone who does notice and is an even better match that Emily – someone you’ve actually talked to and connected with. But even if not, you’ll still be setting yourself up for success after high-school… when your life really will begin.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com