The day a 27-year-old law school grad passed the bar exam, her father, a lawyer himself, began pressuring the daughter to buy a house in Maine near her hometown of Van Buren. He even agreed to cover half the cost if she chose the charming Queen Anne-style property he'd picked out for her.
"At just $199,000, I admit this house is a bargain. And I understand why my folks want me to live near them. But living so rural and close to Canada isn't what I have in mind. I want to practice law in a big city like Boston or Philadelphia," the young lawyer says.
At a time when the hurdles to homeownership have never been higher, advocates for buyers agree that lifestyle and career plans should rule when it comes to neighborhood and property selection. That principle applies to making a purchase in expensive markets as well as bargain ones.
"What's the point of winning in a competitive area if you end up owning a house in the wrong place? Errors in selection can be costly, both emotionally and financially," says Mark Nash, a longtime real estate broker and author of "1001 Tips for Buying & Selling a Home."
In prime neighborhoods, competition among rival buyers is still prompting some young homebuying hopefuls to consider properties they would otherwise have ruled out, like homes in rundown condition or those in neighborhoods not to their liking. But real estate experts fear this could one day lead to disappointment if they compromise too much.
Take the case of a bachelor in his mid-30s. By day, he was a banker, and by night he was part of a vibrant social scene near downtown Los Angeles, where he lived in an apartment. But his family looked on disapprovingly, encouraging him to leave the city for a more conventional suburban existence.
"They urged him to settle down and start living that white-picket-fence lifestyle in the suburbs," recalls Nash, formerly the banker's real estate broker.
Capitulating, the banker bought a ranch-style house built in the 1950s. It was the classic detached suburban place on a quiet street in an outlying suburb, with a garage and an ample yard.
But the man was miserable with his choice. A property that would have been perfect for a family proved a poor pick for a man still on the dating circuit.
In despair, the bank manager phoned Nash, announcing his decision to sell the suburban house just two years after buying it.
"The commute was killing him, he scarcely ever saw his friends, and he told me his Saturday nights were more boring than ever," Nash recalls.
Fortunately, the upswing in value on the suburban house allowed the bachelor to invest his equity in a condo-apartment back in the city. But he still regrets the two dull years he spent in the suburbs.
"Before he bought that place in the burbs, I told him to step back and ask if his family had the same vision that he had for himself. Still, he really didn't think through his decision or stand up to his relatives," Nash says.
Nash urges novice buyers --or anyone considering a radical shift in lifestyle -- to be especially cautious when selecting a property.
"Buyers operating outside their comfort zone can easily make a mistaken choice," he says.
Here are a few pointers for buyers:
-- Talk through expectations with family members.
Many novice purchasers, especially those in their 20s and early 30s, accept parental gifts to help realize their homeownership goal.
"Often, there are a lot of strings attached when the family steps in. There are big control issues, and parental influence can lead to bad decisions," Nash says.
He's noticed that some parents, eager to boast that their children live in a prestige neighborhood, will encourage them to buy beyond their self-imposed limits, which can put pressure on their marriages.
Before you accept family help, you need to know if your parents think this gives them veto rights over your home choice, Nash says.
"A heart-to-heart talk can really help you avert this problem before it arises," he says.
-- Ask lots of questions before picking a property.
You should pose plenty of questions about any home you're considering buying and the community where it's situated, according to Jon Boyd, a real estate broker and past president of the National Association of Exclusive Buyer Agents (naeba.org).
"One simple way to judge a neighborhood is to simply take a walk around the community. It's surprising how many clues you can pick up as you walk. Ideally, you'll chat with local residents to gauge their friendliness level," Boyd says.
Area residents could forewarn you about the annoying freight trains that pass through or the jets with flight paths overhead. They can also tell you about unpleasant traffic problems and issues facing the local schools.
-- Slow down the picking process.
Some longtime renters get so keyed up at the idea of homeownership that they rush into the wrong purchase.
"With all this excitement and newness around their plans, they stop thinking straight," Nash says.
To help guard against the tendency to plunge headlong into a purchase -- a temptation that's especially strong for novice buyers -- Nash suggests that first-time buyers look at multiple properties during a shopping tour, even if they fall in love with the first place they see.
"Don't work with any agent who pressures you into thinking that every house you see is a 'home run'. Think for yourself when choosing a place," he says.
(To contact Ellen James Martin, email her at ellenjamesmartin@gmail.com.)