DEAR DR. BLONZ: Is it possible to eat too many carrots? I usually have about 10 carrots a day. Should I be limiting my intake? -- B.B., El Cerrito, California
DEAR B.B.: That is quite a hefty intake. I have no idea about the rest of your diet, lifestyle or health issues, so there are limits to what I can advise, but carrots would be near the top of any list of healthful foods.
In addition to being a whole food that is high in fiber and low in fat, carrots have a range of beneficial phytochemicals. They have a low glycemic index, meaning that eating raw carrots has a minimal effect on blood sugar levels. When cooked, carrots get a bit sweeter due to the breaking down of some complex carbohydrates into smaller pieces. Still, even cooked, they retain their relatively low glycemic index. Key nutrients in carrots are the carotenoids (coming from the Latin name for "carrot"), which are antioxidant compounds. Beta carotene is the most prominent of these; the body can convert beta carotene into vitamin A as needed.
The bottom line is that carrots are a convenient and colorful addition to the diet. One of my favorites is carrot juice, which I often have as a beverage with my lunch.
All this being said, I am unaware of evidence that would encourage a 10-carrot-a-day habit. This does not negate what carrots have to offer, but it works against the known benefits of variety when eating healthful foods, as each brings its own complement of attributes.
One interesting effect of a large intake of carrots is that you might begin to look like one -- colorwise, that is. In addition to being an antioxidant, beta carotene is a strong colorant, used as an additive to color foods such as cheddar cheese, butter and margarine. Excesses of beta carotene are normally excreted from the body, but there are limits to how rapidly this can take place. It could take up to five days for the excess to leave. When beta carotene intake exceeds the rate at which it can be used or discarded, the body will stash the excess wherever it can.
Our skin, the body's largest organ, plays a role here, taking on an orange tinge as part of a condition called carotenemia. The condition appears on the palms, soles and the center of the face, and is most noticeable in fair-skinned people. Carotenemia is harmless, and the coloring will disappear as soon as the intake of beta carotene is reduced. It is unclear if your carrot habit could create this condition, as it is more common in those taking beta carotene supplements.
In conclusion, carrots are a great food, but they're not a complete diet. A gauge for defining "too many" would be if your carrots leave no room on your plate, or in your stomach, for the other foods your body requires. It might be time to contact your local chapter of Carrot-crunchers Anonymous.
Send questions to: "On Nutrition," Ed Blonz, c/o Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO, 64106. Send email inquiries to questions@blonz.com. Due to the volume of mail, personal replies cannot be provided.