parenting

Social Media Parent Groups Are a Double-Edged Sword

Parents Talk Back by by Aisha Sultan
by Aisha Sultan
Parents Talk Back | October 2nd, 2023

During my four years of college, my mom spoke to exactly one other parent whose child attended the same university.

She met the mother of my best friend. They got along well, but they lived in different cities, so that meeting was the end of their interactions. The extent of communication my parents received about my college life was a weekly long-distance phone call from me.

This is not to say that my parents were unconcerned or uninterested in my life at that time. Back then, parenting was more of a hands-off experience. That was especially true once you dropped off a kid at a college campus.

"Good luck and stay out of trouble" was the general guidance given to us.

Now, we can join private Facebook groups dedicated to the school our child attends. I started joining these groups when my kids were in middle school; they were a good place to keep up with school news or upcoming events I wouldn’t otherwise hear about. I also picked up the school gossip through this online grapevine.

Of course, there’s always some drama when a large group of people gather -- especially virtually. Even that could be entertaining to watch unfold.

I did wonder about the parents who volunteered to moderate these groups, though. Did they ever log off?

When our kids moved up to high school and became more involved in extracurricular activities, I joined the parents’ groups for those organizations. That was in addition to the parents’ pages for the high school itself -- both the official and unofficial versions.

Pretty soon, my Facebook feed was littered with posts from parents I didn’t know personally but whose kids shared something in common with ours, even if it was just attending the same school.

I didn’t expect that this firehose of information would keep flowing when the kids left for college, but it has. Surprisingly, the posts from parents have become more frequent, and more revealing, as their children have gotten older. Parents share about their college kids’ social adjustment issues, loneliness, roommate troubles, course scheduling problems and cafeteria complaints.

It’s hard to imagine my own parents knowing such details about my life when I was that age, let alone sharing them with hundreds of my classmates’ parents. I would have died a thousand deaths if they had revealed that kind of information about me.

But we are in a different era of parenting. We are conditioned to be more involved, solving more problems for our children -- even when it deprives them of learning how to deal with their own challenges and discomforts.

I remember getting a horrible toothache during my freshman year: I had to find a nearby dentist, figure out how to get there, get the tooth extracted and deal with the bill and the aftercare. When my daughter had a toothache at the beginning of her junior year, I asked for advice on the parents’ page and had a list of vetted recommendations in minutes.

A recent Wall Street Journal article described how parents are hiring concierge services to “mother” their college students, doing the sort of tasks a mom might have done at home. It seems like these parents are hiring a cross between an emotional support animal and a butler. The extremely wealthy one-percenters among us have always had access to these types of services, but now this level of handholding has trickled down to the masses.

This does both parents and their children a disservice. A huge part of being a young adult is learning how to function independently. While our parents had little choice but to leave us to our own devices, our generation seems to struggle to give our children the same freedom from parental oversight.

To be fair, many of us are now writing hefty tuition checks, adding a greater layer of financial investment to the situation. The stakes for students also feel much higher. But giving them space to find their way through some challenging situations gives them the confidence that they are capable.

It’s tempting to follow the travails of college life through social media posts from your fellow parents, who may be as anxious as you are about letting go.

However, just because you can, doesn’t mean you should.

parenting

Casting the First Stone -- and the Second and the Third

Parents Talk Back by by Aisha Sultan
by Aisha Sultan
Parents Talk Back | September 25th, 2023

There's something about a struggling single mom that provokes the perfect people.

The perfect people -- those who have always made the best choices and the right decisions -- perk up whenever I write about single mothers in difficult circumstances. Recently, I shared the stories of two such women: a mother of four working at Amazon, and a pregnant mom working at Arby's. Their jobs don’t pay enough to cover child care and basic necessities for their families. It shouldn't be controversial to say that a person working a full-time job in America ought to be able to provide food and shelter for their kids, or that young children obviously need someone to watch them while their parents work.

Hearing these mothers' stories made me feel disgusted that some politicians would rather give trillion-dollar tax cuts to corporations and the wealthiest people than renew a child tax credit that had lifted millions of kids out of poverty.

I was raised to try to imagine other people’s situations and feel compassion for those in bad circumstances. I assume this is how most people are raised.

But reading about these women's hardships triggered a number of people in an entirely different way.

Phillip, for example, wrote this about the mother working 50 to 60 hours a week at Amazon, a company that makes billions in profits: "I have no sympathy for (her) whatsoever ... In most cases having a child is a choice, not an accident. If (she) had given a moment's thought to the consequences of having a child, she would have realized that she couldn't afford one child, much less four."

He was one of several who responded by attacking the life choices of financially strapped moms: How dare they have a child while poor? Why couldn't they just get a better job? Where was the father?

These people seem ignorant of how a person's life circumstances could be different from their own. A few factors to consider: Not everyone goes to schools that prepare them for college or higher-paying jobs. Partners or spouses sometimes leave their families and shirk their responsibilities. In America, 40% to 50% of marriages end in divorce. Some people get sick or marry the wrong person or experience a streak of bad luck.

What kind of bubble must one live in to never have met someone whose life has taken an unexpected or difficult turn while they have children to support?

Also, I'm surprised this has to be spelled out, but a woman cannot control 100% of the factors that can lead to pregnancy: Birth control can fail. Partners can lie or refuse to use contraception. Women can be coerced or pressured into sex.

Conceiving a child is not a one-person job, although the consequences of having a baby disproportionately affect women.

Interestingly, a number of the emails condemning these single working moms came from men. None of them suggested making contraception free and easily accessible. (Birth control can cost up to $2,000 a year, depending on what your doctor recommends.) None of them criticized the complete ban on abortion in Missouri and other states.

You would think that those who want women to avoid having children when it would create a financial strain on their households would also be advocating for reproductive freedom and universal access to birth control.

And regardless of how you feel about a woman's personal choices, why would anyone be against ensuring all babies and children have their basic needs met? Children can't go out and get a job to support themselves. It's pretty heartless to want to see babies born into poverty suffer.

I was taken aback by the lack of empathy -- the angry rants and the blame -- for working moms who can't make ends meet.

Of course, there are also those who respond to these stories by asking how they can help. Not all of us can do that every time we encounter someone in a bad situation.

But it doesn't cost anything to care.

parenting

Pregnant and Powerless

Parents Talk Back by by Aisha Sultan
by Aisha Sultan
Parents Talk Back | September 18th, 2023

Kaamilya Hobbs, eight months pregnant at the time, tried to stay out of her sweltering Kansas City apartment as much as possible during the record-setting heat wave in August.

But there was no escaping the stifling heat and thick humidity at night.

Hobbs, 31, and her partner were behind on their electric bill, and the company had turned their power off earlier in the month. Hobbs tossed and turned in bed for nearly three weeks, barely sleeping. Their 18-month-old baby screamed because it was so hot.

"There was no way to cool him off except for using paper fans," she said.

Hobbs has worked at Arby's for the past four years, where she makes minimum wage. Her schedule had been cut to 20 hours. Her partner lost his job several months ago; he now stays at home with their baby and sells his plasma twice a week.

It hasn't been enough to make ends meet.

"We're trying to make it work," Hobbs said. "But it's very difficult."

In America, twice as many women as men earn the minimum wage. In Missouri, the number of women living in poverty has increased despite more women earning bachelor's degrees. Working full-time at the $12-an-hour minimum wage would earn a Missouri worker just below $25,000 annually. That's assuming not a single day is taken off.

Missouri does not require companies to offer any paid maternity or family leave.

Hobbs said that after her first baby was born, her manager at Arby's asked her to come back to work a week later. She took additional unpaid time off then, but she's not sure what she will do this time.

She and her partner have fallen about $1,400 behind on the rent.

Her due date is Oct. 8.

Her family's eviction date is the next day. They don't have another place to stay yet.

"We have to figure that out," Hobbs said.

During the days when the temperature was over 100 degrees, she focused on staying hydrated, especially since her pregnancy is high-risk. One night, the temperature in their apartment got so high, she couldn't even keep water down. She was throwing up whenever she tried to drink.

She ended up in the emergency room with heat exhaustion.

The lack of power meant they couldn't keep the baby's milk cold in the fridge. They had to switch him back to formula, which doesn't have to be refrigerated. She used the DailyPay program at work, which allows hourly employees to get paid for the hours worked on the same day, just to keep up with diapers and some basic expenses.

"I hate us not being able to provide everything that he needs," she said.

Listening to her story, it's hard to imagine that in a country as wealthy as America, the most vulnerable people live in these conditions: A mother with a baby at home, in her third trimester of pregnancy, is working as many hours as she can get and is still barely hanging on to an apartment without air conditioning or electricity during the hottest days of the year.

It is shameful that it's so difficult to get assistance in these situations.

Hobbs said it was painful for her to share her family's story. She doesn't like asking for help. A social worker has given the family a list of resources to call. Hobbs, who has been exhausted these days, hopes to connect with an organization that might be able to help them find a place to move next month after she gives birth.

Recently, someone at her job heard through the grapevine that her family had been without power for a few weeks.

One of her Arby's co-workers paid off their $500 bill so their lights could be turned back on.

Hobbs found out during one of her shifts and started crying.

"It was really hard for me to hear that," she said. "But I was really grateful for it."

She said she couldn't thank her co-worker enough.

That night, she slept.

Next up: More trusted advice from...

  • Ask Natalie: Fiancé embarrassed to take you to his childhood home? Husband cheated on you when you were pregnant but you don’t want to divorce… but can you forgive him?
  • Ask Natalie: COVID-19 tearing your family apart this holiday season? Dad has dementia…do you have to visit every day?
  • Ask Natalie: Daughter left a cult but family not welcoming her home? Brother divorcing and doesn’t want to share the holiday with his ex?
  • Last Word in Astrology for December 09, 2023
  • Last Word in Astrology for December 08, 2023
  • Last Word in Astrology for December 07, 2023
  • Panforte di Siena: A Holiday Cake Confection
  • A Hummus Makeover
  • ‘Tis the Season for Holiday Leftovers
UExpressLifeParentingHomePetsHealthAstrologyOdditiesA-Z
AboutContactSubmissionsTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
©2023 Andrews McMeel Universal