DEAR MISS MANNERS: Sometimes people enthusiastically tell me something they think I don’t know, particularly about my areas of expertise. Saying "I already knew that" sounds condescending. Pretending I didn’t know, and saying something like “That’s interesting,” seems passive-aggressive.
I have been accused of competing in the first case and lying by omission in the second. Could you please recommend a polite and kind way to respond?
GENTLE READER: This is a case for the improv convention of “yes and.”
You listen politely and take it from there -- elaborating on the subject, skipping the responses you have tried in the past.
Miss Manners will not object if your taking up the conversation shows that you know far more about the subject than the person who began it -- perhaps even more than they are capable of understanding.