life

Group ‘Ownership’ of Baby Puts New Mom on Edge

Miss Manners by by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Miss Manners | January 5th, 2010

DEAR MISS MANNERS: I am 25 years old and currently pregnant with our first child. At a morning prayer group for the women of my church, my mother and mother-in-law were both present (fortunately, I am on excellent terms with both) and the majority of women were their friends or women of the generation above theirs.

Almost all of them knew my husband and me as we grew up and so feel deeply connected with us, even though (in most cases) our actual interactions have been very limited.

At one point, one of them commented to me that "you might be carrying it, but it's really our baby." The other women all smiled and agreed.

They weren't serious, of course, but it wasn't just a joke, either. Since I had no desire to make a scene, I let it pass, but I found the comment very upsetting.

Am I right to be upset? My mother agrees that it was in poor taste but doesn't seem to think it's a big deal. I expect my internal reaction is probably stronger than it should be, as is common during pregnancy. I have no intention of bringing the matter up again.

What do I do next time, if there should be one? I'll see these women again, after all. I don't wish to offend them (for one thing, I'm certain it was meant lovingly; for another, offending a potential source of free babysitting seems like bad policy), but I would prefer to retain some ownership of my own baby.

GENTLE READER: Sorry, but you will not own your baby. Owning human beings is immoral and illegal.

And in the milder sense in which Miss Manners understands that you intended, it is unwise. These people were not plotting to kidnap your baby. They are not denying that you are the mother.

They are, as you acknowledge, lovingly expressing their feeling of connection with your family. Your child is fortunate to be born into a caring community. You, too, are lucky. You may or may not get free babysitting, but you will be assured an eager response when you want to go around showing off baby pictures and reporting baby development.

DEAR MISS MANNERS: For Christmas, I received many, many gift certificates from well-meaning relatives. Personally, I spend a great deal of time picking presents that I think people will like and have meaning and significance to our relationship. I always feel somewhat put off when all I receive in return is a $20 gift certificate to a bookstore. Am I being outdated our overly sensitive?

GENTLE READER: Your relatives probably think it is over-sensitive and outdated to expect anyone to put thought into choosing a present. Or perhaps they considered that pairing you with the stores they chose is quite enough thought about you. Miss Manners only hopes they also thought to check the expiration date and other policies of the store that so often interfere with the recipients getting a present at all.

:

life

Are Thank You Notes for Bonuses Appropriate?

Miss Manners by by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Miss Manners | January 3rd, 2010

DEAR MISS MANNERS: The small company I work for hands out Christmas bonuses every year. The last two years I have been with the company, I have received a bonus, but I was not sure as to whether or not I should send a thank you note to the owner, so I didn't. Once again, I'm torn -- do I write a thank you note or don't I?

I was always told as a child that when you receive a gift, the proper thing to do would be to send the giver a thank you note. Are bonuses considered a gift or is it a thank you from the employer for your contribution to the business for the last year? Should one write a thank you note for their thanking you? What is the proper way to accept Christmas Bonuses?

GENTLE READER: With gracious thanks.

Miss Manners cannot imagine where you got the idea that thanks are only for what is undeserved. Or that you should err on the side of nonthanks when there is a doubt.

Why, people who are after your job have been sending thank you letters to your personnel department just for interviewing them. Surely you can squeeze out a word of thanks for the company's having rewarded you, whether or not it was expected or contracted.

DEAR MISS MANNERS: How do you deal with grandchildren, age 5, age 10 and age 15, who have not learned or been guided by their parents in courtesies such as thank you notes?

As a grandparent, I feel a moral obligation to provide positive guidance but don't know the best (if any) way to go about it. One such effort, what I thought was a courteous note to the parents, resulted in a hostile reply. And curtailing future gifts to young children whose parents' neglect is responsible seems inappropriate.

GENTLE READER: Indeed, a grandparent should provide guidance, most notably to the parents two decades or longer before they become parents. Should these people lapse once they have outgrown such jurisdiction, their elders will have to do it all over again.

But not the same way, Miss Manners cautions them. As you have discovered, they cannot, with impunity, issue directives that contradict or criticize their grandchildren's parents.

They are thus reduced to appealing to the children's reason.

Choose some time when you have been playing happily with them, so they will not interpret your remarks as scolding.

"I wonder if I did something wrong," you might muse. The prospect of a confession of wrong-doing from their seniors is of great interest to children.

Pressed for an explanation, you say, "I enjoy selecting presents for all of you, because I imagine them making you happy. But I must be wrong, because I never hear a word from you about them -- not even whether they arrived, and never that you liked them.

"Should I stop sending them?"

There will be a chorus of "No!" after which you can say gently, "then I will expect some feedback from each of you."

DEAR MISS MANNERS: Now that the holidays are over, I seem to be bombarded with thank you notes from recipients of my gifts. Is this a common practice? I have recently moved to a new city and had not received thank you notes for gifts in the past, unless it were for a wedding or baby shower. Is it a new rule to give a thank you note for any gift, regardless of the occasion? Christmas, birthdays, etc.? If so, I have millions to catch up on!

GENTLE READER: Get busy.

:

life

Would You Care for a Dance? No, Not You

Miss Manners by by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Miss Manners | December 31st, 2009

DEAR MISS MANNERS: What's the correct way for a man to choose or change dance partners without making others feel bad?

I've been going to a social dance club. I normally show up without a date, as do several other men and women. I'm there just for an evening's diversion.

I don't want anyone to feel left out. How do I ask one woman to dance without making the woman next to her feel like lesser goods? Is there a polite way to stop dancing with a current partner so I can ask a woman who's been left sitting? I've gotten to know some of the women who are regulars, but others are strangers to me.

GENTLE READER: A gentleman should never leave a lady stranded on or near a dance floor -- a rule that has led to desperate signals in the attempt to palm off a dance partner with whom he does not wish to continue.

So if no one leaps over to take her off his hands, he finishes the dance, thanks the lady and escorts her back to join others on the sidelines, where he found her. Similarly, he does not whisk a lady to the dance floor if she is with only one other lady, who would then be stranded (which is why ladies should not stand around in pairs). But if he must, he should say to the remaining lady, "And may I engage you for the next dance?"

DEAR MISS MANNERS: Please address the proper use of the chargers that are so popular today. Everyone seems to have a different idea.

Is it put on the table and left there throughout the meal, removing the salad plate and replacing it with the dinner plate, etc.; or is the dinner plate put on the charger and salad plate put on top of it? One friend says she's so glad to use it because she doesn't have to use a place mat.

GENTLE READER: Is she going to put the food on the tabletop when it is removed? Or will that stack of dishes, one on top of the other, fall over first?

The charger, or place plate ("charger" sounds too aggressive for Miss Manners), is set at each place at the start of the meal, and a soup plate or other smaller first-course plate may be set on it. However, it must then be removed and replaced by the dinner plate. It is not allowed to stay for the entire meal.

DEAR MISS MANNERS: My husband is very unusual -- he likes to do the thank you notes, birthdays, etc. He probably sends over 500 notes a year.

Recently, he sent a mutual friend of ours a sympathy card, for her brother, whom we did not know -- and now she is put out with me for the fact that I did not sign it also. Isn't his signature adequate to suffice?

GENTLE READER: His signature, yes. Only one person can write, and therefore should sign, a letter. But does he not know to include you in the text, as in "Imogene and I were so sorry to hear..."?

Miss Manners gives him great credit for doing a noble job, one that was once the sole burden of wives. If that disgruntled and ungrateful recipient objects merely because he is the family letter-writer, do not let it trouble you.

:

Next up: More trusted advice from...

  • 7 Day Menu Planner for March 26, 2023
  • 7 Day Menu Planner for March 19, 2023
  • 7 Day Menu Planner for March 12, 2023
  • A Place of Peace
  • Is My Self-Care Selfish?
  • Transportable Tranquility
  • The Worst Part of Waiting for College Admissions
  • Taking a Life-Changing Risk
  • Reversing the Rise in Dangerous Driving
UExpressLifeParentingHomePetsHealthAstrologyOdditiesA-Z
AboutContactSubmissionsTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
©2023 Andrews McMeel Universal