life

Assumptions About a PH.D.

Miss Manners by by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Miss Manners | February 15th, 2001

DEAR MISS MANNERS: I have a job in a scientific organization at a fairly high level. Most people who have attained this level are Ph.Ds. I am not, but I frequently find myself being introduced as "Dr."

What is the most gracious way of correcting people? In some situations, such as a speaker or at international forums, it may be impossible, but in others it might be appropriate. In correspondence, this is easier to right.

GENTLE READER: Unfortunately, you can't go around saying, "I don't have a Ph.D." Miss Manners cannot explain why it seems as boastful to brag about not having a degree as it is to brag about having one, but such is the case.

As you note, you cannot go around correcting people, but in correspondence you can use the title "Mrs." as you did in the return address, or in parentheses beneath your signature. Beyond that, you can only say quietly to those likely to repeat the mistake, "Oh, by the way, it's 'Mrs. Worthington,' not 'Dr. Worthington.'"

That this may lead some to believe that you not only have a Ph.D. but are modest and confident enough to refrain from using the title is neither your problem nor Miss Manners' fault.

DEAR MISS MANNERS: My spouse and I had his widowed mother and younger (adult) brother as our guests at our vacation home last summer. We were happy to assume the financial burden such an expensive trip would have put on them, as we are in a better situation than they and thought they would appreciate seeing the area and spending time with us.

We were therefore rather dismayed when, upon arrival, my brother-in-law demanded that we pay the additional cost to add his name to the rental car agreement so he wouldn't be "stuck" with us the whole time. My husband explained that we could not afford it, and his brother let the issue drop, rather than volunteering to pay it himself.

Several times during their stay, I asked their mother to perform some minuscule function to assist me in my chores, and I was met each time with the response, "I'm not doing anything -- I'm on vacation!" And she didn't.

On another occasion, after I had listened politely to my brother-in-law recounting a story which was of absolutely no interest to me whatsoever, I requested his attention for what would have been perhaps 10 seconds, to look at some information on my computer screen. He immediately shot back with, "I'm not interested," and ignored me. I was hurt, but said nothing about his behavior at the time, in the interest of harmony.

My husband, who had observed his brother's behavior, explained to him that he had just been very rude to me, but failed to elicit an apology. His brother later wandered away at a crowded public event and was missing for over an hour. Upon my husband's finding him and escorting him back, no explanation or apology was offered, and I chose not to make a scene. I informed my husband privately before they left that, because of their inconsiderate behavior, they were never being invited back, and he agreed.

Now, we understand that they have both fallen in love with our summer home and are intending to return next summer. How do you suggest that we handle this?

GENTLE READER: How about lending it to them for a weekend? No, bad idea. Miss Manners supposes they would submit an expense account for food and incidentals.

It is not as easy to avoid inviting relatives as others, because relatives speak up more readily, and because they have ways of finding out what you are doing. So here is what you are doing:

Next summer, you may be having some guests, but only those who help out; you are also planning to have a real vacation yourself, free of the need to wait on guests. Since having guests and not having guests are the only possibilities, that should cover whatever you want to do.

Should the reply be that they will help, you should demur by saying, "Oh, no, I'm sure you don't want to run the household while I get rested." Perhaps skipping a summer will put them in a better frame of mind.

:

life

Hugging on a First Date

Miss Manners by by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Miss Manners | February 13th, 2001

DEAR MISS MANNERS: Participation in a dating service has yielded me a dozen first dates in the past few months, and they have been wonderful fun. However, at the conclusion of the dates, the men typically want to hug.

While I believe their intent is innocent, I find the expectation of a hug from someone I have known for just a few hours to be both presumptuous and inappropriate, and I am growing increasingly uncomfortable with the situation.

When I try to pre-empt their gesture by extending my hand for a handshake, these men either overlook it, discount it, or just open their arms and lean in, regardless of my reluctance.

What can I do to graciously decline these advances for a hug (and in some cases, a kiss, too) while letting the man know I've enjoyed his company and leaving the door open for a second date?

GENTLE READER: Many people now confuse a hug with a handshake. Almost as many as those who confuse a date with an assignation.

Miss Manners doesn't know which sort of confusion afflicts your new friends. Perhaps both. The two are not as mutually exclusive as logic might suggest.

But as you like these gentlemen anyway, she will not consider a solution that would permanently disabuse them of the desire to hug you. Reaching back to times that moved more slowly, she suggests that you jump back and say provocatively, "Oh dear, I never hug on the first date."

DEAR MISS MANNERS: My girlfriend and I have been seeing each other for two years, and we generally cook for each other when at each other's homes. I also take her out once in a while, and when we do a project at the other's home, the visiting person gets taken to dinner or made dinner for his or her efforts.

At my house (and I've told her this) I have the position that whatever is in the fridge is open for her to indulge herself. Basically, whatever is mine is hers, and I've told her there's no reason to even ask, just to take what she wants.

In recent months, my girlfriend will call me out or make dinner and then accuse me of "sponging." On occasion, I've helped myself to juice, and I'll get a comment like, "Just drink water." Am I overstepping my boundaries?

She's intimated that she expects the man to pay for all outings. Is that fair? And with my being hospitable to her in my home? I just did my taxes (I keep all receipts), and I spent over $4,000 just on entertainment, not to mention presents on Valentine's Day, birthdays, Christmas, etc.

I think it's just rude to ask someone out and then criticize them because they accept, or to tell me to drink water after I've extended the use of the beverages and food at my home.

GENTLE READER: Miss Manners is sorry to tell you that it won't help you in the least to have her side with you. The lady in question is deeply miffed at you, and water and juice have nothing to do with it.

Whether or not the situation is terminal, Miss Manners cannot say. It is possible that the lady is irritated because she wants a bond that is not merely that of two friends trying to be fair -- marriage being what comes to mind. It is also possible that what irritates her is the sight of you, and that what she wants is to put you out of her life as well as her refrigerator.

In neither case would it help to bring out all the receipts to show her how much you spent on her. This is one of those rare situations in which Miss Manners recommends what everyone else recommends for all situations, including those best left alone: Sit down with the lady and ask her gently what is really bothering her.

:

life

Handling Drop-in Guests

Miss Manners by by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Miss Manners | February 8th, 2001

DEAR MISS MANNERS: How does one handle uninvited guests who refuse to give you any advance warning? A family I know have, on more than one occasion, just dropped by unannounced and, as they have subsequently informed me, they are shocked to find that I am not at home. This family never suggests making an appointment so that I will definitely be at home when they arrive. Should I feel pressured to make an appointment with them at my home? How should this situation be handled?

GENTLE READER: Miss Manners hopes this family is not your family, because they seem a bit slow. Why should they be shocked to find that people are not always at home? Even they are not at home; they're out dropping in on you.

Perhaps if you continue to be not at home when they call, they will get the idea and call ahead. Miss Manners recommends window shades or, if you happen to get caught opening the door in the hope that it was the mail delivery, an apologetic, "Oh, I'm so sorry, we can't see you now, please do call to arrange a good time" followed by a wave as you shut the door.

DEAR MISS MANNERS: Can you please give an opinion to help settle a problem before somebody gets diced with my electric carving knife?

I say that when you sit down to eat, you should eat without getting up and deciding that you have to have some added condiment or item. I set the table thoroughly and prepare good and varied meals three times a day. But it seems that there is always something missing and that somebody has to get up and go to the refrigerator.

I tell them that if they were in a restaurant they would not go into the kitchen and retrieve something and their reply is that they are at home and want to feel comfortable.

Getting up reminds me of teen-aged boys who push their chairs back from the table and have to go get a coke or pickles or something like that. I have suggested eating in front of the refrigerator with the doors open so that one could reach right in, but the layout of our kitchen won't permit this.

When we are invited to somebody's house for a meal, I am satisfied with what is on the table. I wouldn't think of asking for something or going to help myself to something additional. I was told that "everybody does it," but I don't believe it.

I realize that we are in the age of Slobus Americanus Rex, but surely there must be some set of manners or standards. We are all waiting for a reply and you better hurry -- otherwise I might be writing to you from behind bars the next time one of my family members decides they have to get up and get some sliced cheese to put on my homemade chili.

GENTLE READER: There, there. You're a little overworked, aren't you? And perhaps a little hurt that those for whom you cook want to make adjustments to the food?

Miss Manners begs you to put down the carving knife, and be reasonable. It is true that people would not pop up from the table when eating out, but also that in a restaurant they would have ordered what they wanted and asked a waiter to fetch anything that was missing, while in somebody's house, they would have had to accept what they might not like.

Things should be different at home, but not because they needn't have manners. It would be the greater part of politeness for these people to set the table with whatever they might require, thus relieving you from some of the work, as well as from their absences.

:

Next up: More trusted advice from...

  • 7 Day Menu Planner for March 26, 2023
  • 7 Day Menu Planner for March 19, 2023
  • 7 Day Menu Planner for March 12, 2023
  • A Place of Peace
  • Is My Self-Care Selfish?
  • Transportable Tranquility
  • The Worst Part of Waiting for College Admissions
  • Taking a Life-Changing Risk
  • Reversing the Rise in Dangerous Driving
UExpressLifeParentingHomePetsHealthAstrologyOdditiesA-Z
AboutContactSubmissionsTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
©2023 Andrews McMeel Universal