DEAR SOMEONE ELSE’S MOM: My husband won’t say anything to his parents, but he is deeply hurt and offended by his parents making his younger sister the executor of their wills. His dad called him to tell him that was their decision, but not why.
My husband is a paralegal in a corporate law office, and has much more legal knowledge than his sister. She and her husband own a car detailing company. They’re doing OK in it, and just built a big new house in a nice area. So obviously, they know some of what they’re doing businesswise.
But why would they pick my sister-in-law, who has no legal experience, to do such an important job? God willing, it’s one that won’t be called on to be done for many, many years, but it clearly bothers and confuses my husband. --- WHY NOT THEIR SON
DEAR WHY NOT THEIR SON: Although they haven’t shared it with your husband yet, your in-laws no doubt have their reasons for appointing your sister-in-law and not your husband as executor of their wills.
It’s possible they may feel your sister-in-law has a schedule that that better enables her to take on another responsibility — and make no mistake, being the executor of a will can be a time-consuming and demanding responsibility.
It’s also possible they didn’t want to put your husband on the spot, simply because he has a legal background. Think of the CPA in a family who’s constantly getting hit up for financial advice, or the cousin in the medical field everyone calls for a free diagnosis.
The only way your husband’s going to discover his parents’ motive for choosing his sister instead of him is to politely and calmly ask them directly.
If they prefer not to say, that’s their prerogative, and the best your husband can do in any case is to respect his parents’ wishes and let his sister know he’s around to help if she needs it when the time comes.