DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I am aroace and terrified that no one will ever love me or invest in me emotionally. I would like a “normal” monogamous relationship in which I build a life with someone, but I know the odds of that happening are extremely slim.
I know that my small-town life is a big contributing factor, but my job is literally the only thing in my life that brings me joy. Multiple therapists have turned me down when I bring this issue to them.
Please help me feel like I have a future where I am loved and cherished bc I just do not see it.
No Future
DEAR NO FUTURE: Under normal circumstances, I don’t question people’s self-identification but… are you sure you’re aromantic? I’m asking in part because, well, it sure seems like you’re hoping to fall in love and haven’t yet, rather than not being capable of it.
Don’t get me wrong, aro people aren’t Vulcans; they experience a wide gamut of emotions and connections, just not romantic love. But it’s not very often that you find someone who’s aro – solidly aro – who is hoping for what would ultimately be a one-sided love with someone whose affection would, by definition, be unrequited.
I’m also not precisely sure what a “normal” monogamous relationship in this case would bring you that is so important that you’re terrified that you’ll never have one. Is it solidity? Comfort? Is it the belief that a “normal”, monogamous relationship will mean that your future partner will never leave you or develop feelings or an attraction for another person who might return those feelings and desires in ways that you – again, by definition, can’t? Because I hate to be the one to tell you this but monogamy isn’t a magic spell. People in closed relationships and who make monogamous commitments develop feelings for other people, develop attraction to other people all the time. Monogamy just means you agree not to have sex with other people, not that you won’t want to.
And to be perfectly blunt: a “normal” monogamous relationship with someone who isn’t also aroace in very specific ways is going to be a tall order. The vast majority of people out there are allosexual, and a sexual connection with their partner tends to be near the top of the list of priorities of what they want in a relationship. The desire for sex is one of the most primal drives in humans, and sex almost always wins in the end, no matter what we say and no matter the consequences.
If you’re hoping to find someone who’s willing to give up sex with anyone except themselves… well, I’m not going to say that those people don’t exist, I know folks who are in precisely that relationship, but you will be looking for a very specific needle in a haystack made of other needles. If you’re willing to make that search, then good luck and God speed… just be willing to acknowledge that this is the tallest of tall orders and you may be single for a lot longer than you might prefer.
Now, maybe the issue at hand is “normal”. “Normal” is kind of a meaningless word when it comes to people and relationships; it implies that there’s a natural order to things when in reality, “normal” really just means “in the mainstream”. What we consider to be a “normal” relationship today would be considered insane 500 years ago, when sages and philosophers all agreed that romantic love was an absurd thing to base a relationship on; it was far too volatile and capricious to serve as a foundation for building a home and raising a family. All “normal” does is put the stamp of societal approval on something without ever considering whether it’s actually a good fit for everyone involved, meets anyone’s needs or even works as intended.
So, maybe what you want is to let go of “normal” and the narrative of a spouse or the idea that romantic love is the end goal. After all, people can love and cherish you without being romantically in love with you. People build lives and families – loving, happy, successful households and families – without being in romantic love. Family don’t end in blood, after all; family is what you make it. The family you’re assigned at the start of the game is just that: the family you’re assigned. You can find and build a new one if the one you’re assigned isn’t a good fit.
Perhaps what you should be looking for isn’t “normal” monogamy; you should look for people you love – as in philia and storge, not eros – and who you mesh with. Your partner who loves and cherishes you and supports you can be your best friend, your sibling in all but blood. Your connection may not be “normal”, but what good is “normal” when you aren’t “normal”? Why waste the time trying to sand off your corners and edges to fit into a round hole when you’re a perfectly good square peg already?
Sometimes the issue isn’t that you can’t find what you’re looking for. Sometimes it’s that you’re trying to force yourself into something that’s a bad fit, like trying to wedge your feet into shoes that are the wrong size and shape. You may be able to accomplish it, but not without pain and blisters, hindering your ability to walk and running the risk of an infection that will ultimately cost you far more than you realize.
I think if you take a little time to consider why “normal” is supposed to be so important to you and ask if maybe there are other ways that these needs could be met – even if they’re not “typical” – you might be a lot happier, and a lot less afraid.
All will be well.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com