DEAR DR. BLONZ: I am interested in the health benefits of plant phytochemicals, and you include chocolate among them. Are the phytochemical antioxidants in the cocoa powder or in the cocoa fat? If they are in the fat, does that mean the only way to get the benefits is to eat full-fat chocolate? -- M.D., Raleigh, North Carolina
DEAR M.D.: Successful plants evolved the ability to capture energy from the sun, using it to fuel the construction of their complex structures and substances and power all aspects of their metabolism. (We rely on the foods we eat to provide our energy.) But, aside from serving as an essential source for energy, the sun's rays can have devastating effects on living tissues. Similar to the visible effects of sunlight bleaching colors, excessive exposure to the sun's oxidizing rays can damage tissues and cause cancer.
While animals develop skin adapted to their habitats, they can move and find shade and shelter. Plants remain anchored by their roots; successful ones have evolved appropriate defenses for every stage of their life cycle. The most straightforward protections are shields in the form of opaque barriers. Examples in nature include leaves and seed coverings. We rely on hats, umbrellas and sunscreen applied directly to protect our skin, but critical are the antioxidants that can inhibit oxidative damage to body tissues and substances. We find antioxidants and other protective phytochemicals in the fruit and leaves that are exposed to the environment. Likewise, plants that tend to have higher levels of fats and oils will usually have lipid antioxidants on call.
Most basic to this discussion is an appreciation that phytochemical protectants are there for the plant's benefit, not ours! Every plant has evolved its own protection strategy, underscoring the wisdom of including a variety of plant-based foods in the daily diet. It is only when such foods are a regular part of what we are eating that they can be there to work their magic for us when needed. For more on antioxidants, see b.link/tb55h26.
As you pointed out, research on chocolate has identified its variety of beneficial compounds. The primary antioxidant phytochemicals in cocoa beans are the flavonols, a type of flavonoid found in the solid fraction of chocolate. These are in the cocoa powder and, of course, in the whole chocolate confection. Dark chocolate tends to contain more than milk chocolate, with white chocolate containing little, if any. As for whether having cocoa powder is a better way of getting the benefits of the chocolate, that, I think, is a matter of personal preference. For more on the benefits of chocolate, see b.link/m7wkbxs.
There are plenty of foods with wonderful attributes. Eat chocolate, not because it is prescriptive, but because you enjoy it.
Send questions to: "On Nutrition," Ed Blonz, c/o Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. Send email inquiries to questions@blonz.com. Due to the volume of mail, personal replies cannot be provided.