DEAR DR. FOX: I appreciated your column addressing the risks to dogs and cats of using insecticides even when they don’t have fleas, ticks or internal parasites. Giving pets these pesticide treatments as a preventative is like taking an aspirin every day just in case you might get a headache.
Advertisement
I found FDA data on the internet about reported adverse reactions and deaths after administration of flea and tick treatments, and the numbers are horrifying. As just one example, the FDA reports that Simparica Trio killed 6,700 dogs in less than a year. It took Trifexis 10 years to kill roughly the same number of dogs (6,600). It's no wonder that the petition below has over 24,000 signatures to pull this killing drug off the market!
Add your signature to pull Simparica from the marketplace and start a class-action lawsuit: change.org/p/petition-for-the-immediate-withdrawal-of-simparica-flea-tick-treatment-from-the-market.
Also, see this related news release from 2021: beyondpesticides.org/dailynewsblog/2021/03/despite-1700-dog-deaths-from-flea-collars. -- B.G., Minneapolis
DEAR B.G.: You have certainly done some research on these products, which are widely used and unconditionally endorsed by too many veterinarians. These drugs are also documented as serious environmental contaminants that affect aquatic life when dogs get into freshwater ecosystems.
Over-the-counter sales of flea and tick products that contain neurotoxic, endocrine-disrupting and possibly carcinogenic ingredients should be prohibited. Veterinarians should never prescribe them as routine preventatives in uninfested pets, but only as a last-resort emergency treatment. This also includes collars for dogs and cats containing tetrachlorvinphos (TCVP), an organophosphate insecticide that works by disrupting the nervous system of the targeted insects. Exposure to organophosphate insecticides can cause a range of health problems in humans -- from respiratory failure and seizures to developmental issues and increased risk of certain cancers. Children exposed to these insecticidal chemicals on pets in their homes are at risk. Acute exposure to these chemicals can be fatal, especially if it leads to respiratory failure.
Additionally, many chemicals that contaminate our home environments can cause hypothyroidism. Per a 2023 study: "There is considerable evidence to indicate that exposure to the insecticides organochlorines, organophosphates and pyrethroids increased (the) risk of hypothyroidism. Exposure to herbicides also increased risk of hypothyroidism." (See the study "Exposure to pesticides and the risk of hypothyroidism: a systematic review and meta-analysis" by Wachiranun Sirikul and Ratana Sapbamrer, published in BMC Public Health, 2023.)
The 2022 debacle with Seresto flea collars -- where nearly 2,700 animal deaths were reported, along with more than 100,000 incidents of harm, according to the EPA’s records -- was deplorable. Sadly, even with this evidence presented to the EPA, Elanco has been allowed to continue sales. Absolutely absurd -- and, of course, not good for dogs and cats. For details, find the news release by going to biologicaldiversity.org and searching for "Seresto."
Visit earthanimal.com and adorepet.us to find various botanical products that help prevent fleas, ticks and mosquitoes from infesting and possibly infecting dogs and cats with insect-borne diseases. Earth Animal products include supplements, repellant collars, sprays, topical treatments and shampoos. AdorePet sells an Herbal Defense Powder, to be mixed daily with your pet’s food, that contains several natural ingredients that help repel biting insects.
With the documented harms of using insecticides on companion animals -- as well as the risks they pose to humans, especially children in the home -- these safe and effective alternatives are a wise choice. For more ways to prevent fleas, ticks and mosquitoes from harming your pet, see my post here: drfoxonehealth.com/post/preventing-fleas-ticks-and-mosquitoes.
Another concern of mine is the widely advertised and prescribed drug Apoquel to treat dogs with itchy skin, with the side note “not to be used in dogs younger than 12 months.” This drug suppresses the immune system and can have harmful side effects. It provides a quick and profitable way to stop dogs from scratching themselves without addressing the cause, which could be dietary or environmental. See my critique posted here: drfoxonehealth.com/post/apoquel-risks-and-alternatives-for-dogs-with-atopic-dermatitis.
(Send all mail to animaldocfox@gmail.com or to Dr. Michael Fox in care of Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. The volume of mail received prohibits personal replies, but questions and comments of general interest will be discussed in future columns.
Visit Dr. Fox’s website at DrFoxOneHealth.com.)