DEAR DR. FOX: I am very concerned about how animals are raised for consumption. I understand most are raised in confined animal feeding operations. These factories are not only inhumane, but can also lead to water depletion and contamination.
I read that the FDA has approved certain lab-grown meats. Although it sounds strange, this could be a win-win: It could supply cheap meat for carnivores and prevent animals from enduring the terrible treatment in factories and feedlots. What is your opinion? -- L.H., Cleveland Heights, Ohio
DEAR L.H.: There are some legitimate questions concerning consumer safety and environmental risk with genetically engineered foods, which I raised in my 2004 book "Killer Foods: When Scientists Manipulate Genes, Better is Not Always Best."
As Michael Nevradakis, Ph.D., writes at The Defender (ChildrensHealthDefense.org): "Describing the development as 'a food revolution,' the U.S. Food and Drug Administration has declared lab-grown chicken meat developed by Berkeley, California-based food-tech firm Upside Foods to be safe for human consumption."
But there are still questions to be answered. Another company in this industry, Reboot Food, released a "manifesto" in November. Per its website, Reboot Food is "a campaign of the citizen-led green group RePlanet to phase out animal agriculture for new sustainable alternatives," and in the process, see the farming of plants revolutionized to use less land and fewer chemicals and see our planet rewilded. The pitch continues (as posted on TheAlternative.org): "Thanks to breakthroughs in the tried-and-tested technique of precision fermentation used to brew yeasts and bacteria into plant-based and animal-free proteins (already used widely to produce animal-free rennet and insulin), food innovators have now unlocked the keys to make animal-free proteins and fats that are biologically identical (and just as delicious) as those we currently get from cows and other livestock."
This appropriate use of biotechnology needs government and private investor support, and the urgency of its adoption cannot be overstated as a major remedy for climate change and loss of biodiversity. It would also hasten the end of the suffering and slaughter of billions of animals, dramatically reducing diseases that can spread to humans and wildlife. For more details, go to RebootFood.org.
Philip Steir, head of Alternative Proteins at Earth Animal, writes to me that the Better Meat Company and many others are now creating meat from fermentation and mycelium. Wild Type (wildtypefoods.com) is growing real salmon meat from cells, and has already partnered with famous sushi chefs and dozens of restaurants. They are awaiting FDA approval. The Good Meat Company (goodmeat.co) is building huge cultivated meat facilities in California, Singapore and Qatar. Good Meat is currently approved to sell in Singapore, and is in talks with U.S. federal agencies. Also see Mission Barns (missionbarns.com), which is producing a mix of cultivated pork fat and plant-based proteins -- while the pig their bacon comes from is alive and well on an animal sanctuary in Sonoma! And Clara Foods, now changed and rebranded as The Every Company (theeverycompany.com), is working towards creating the world's first animal-free egg white and a slew of other performance protein products for sports nutrition, baking, and industrial uses.
Steir tells me most of the companies he knows, including Upside Foods, are not using fetal bovine serum, which is one concern some critics have raised.
For details go to: upsidefoods.com/animal-component-free-upsides-cell-feed-breakthrough-levels-up-the-future-of-cultivated-meat.
He states unequivocally, "The positive scope of cultivated meat, to me, is extensive ... and has the ability to address environmental concerns that come with conventional meat. The promising future will be that cultivated meat consumes far less energy, land, and water. It is cruelty- and slaughter-free, and environmentally so much better.
"Additionally, this cultured cell-based meat is produced in a highly controlled environment, which can protect the meat from microbes and contamination. E. coli, Salmonella, Lysteria, Campylobacter are intestinal pathogens that cause illnesses every year ... (but) there are no intestinal organs in lab-grown meat, so there cannot be contamination during slaughter. It's also meat free from the growth hormones and vaccines that are often injected into farm animals."
I agree with Steir's assertions and excellent synopsis, and see this alternative food biotechnology as a significant step to ending farm animal factories and helping reduce our carbon footprint and slow climate change and the loss of biodiversity.
PART 2 of this response will be posted in next week's column.
(Send all mail to animaldocfox@gmail.com or to Dr. Michael Fox in care of Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. The volume of mail received prohibits personal replies, but questions and comments of general interest will be discussed in future columns.
Visit Dr. Fox’s website at DrFoxOneHealth.com.)