DEAR READERS: Consumers and producers of farmed animal products -- meats, eggs and dairy -- are responding to the documented threats to public health, animal welfare and the environment associated with intensive factory farm systems: the so-called CAFOs (confined/concentrated animal feeding operations).
Regarding the environmental effects of these facilities, writer Devatha P. Nair recently posted an article on SentientMedia.org entitled, "Most Factory Farms Have 'Free Pass' to Pollute the Environment." An excerpt:
"Emissions from factory farms in the United States now cause more deaths than traditional polluting industries such as coal-fired plants, with air pollution coming from agriculture accounting for 17,900 deaths every year," writes Nair. (Source: scientific journal PNAS, the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, "Air quality-related health damages of food," Nina G.G. Domingo et al, May 10, 2021)
"And yet," continues Nair, "factory farming is one of the least regulated industries by the Environmental Protection Agency. Most farms are currently protected by an amnesty deal that protects the industry's biggest players from any meaningful enforcement of environmental protection laws. The inability of the EPA to regulate the livestock industry led to 24 advocacy organizations filing a legal petition to enforce federal air pollution laws against high-polluting farms, which the agency has refused to do for nearly two decades. The groups are asking the EPA to stop giving factory farms a free pass to pollute and start doing more to protect communities and the environment."
Another new report, this one from the Center for Biological Diversity and World Animal Protection, also addresses this issue. The report analyzes the use of six pesticides commonly sprayed on crops that are ultimately used to feed factory-farmed pigs, poultry and cattle. According to the report, 235 million pounds of pesticides were used on corn and soybean crops in 2018. The authors assert that all of the pesticides and herbicides listed in the report threaten the flora and fauna of the ecosystems surrounding the crops they are used on. (Source: "Collateral Damage: How Factory Farming Drives Up the Use of Toxic Agricultural Pesticides," reports.worldanimalprotection.org/US/Pesticides)
On the animal welfare front, factory-farmed animals suffer from inherited health problems as a consequence of genetic selection for very rapid growth (for more flesh/meat and fat) and productivity (of eggs and milk). And things get even worse when illnesses strike: As avian flu spreads through the poultry industry, millions of broiler chickens, laying hens and turkeys are being culled en masse. Veterinarians are among those demanding an end to some of the cruelest killing methods, such as ventilation shutdown, causing death by suffocation and hyperthermia. (Source: "'They're Cooking Them Alive': Calls to Ban 'Cruel' Killing Methods on U.S. Farms," The Guardian, March 8)
Though some laws are in place, they are limited in their reach. The Animal Welfare Act, which sets minimum standards for animals used in zoos or research or sold as pets, specifically exempts animals raised for food. The Humane Methods of Slaughter Act and the 28-Hour Law (the latter of which covers farmed animals in transport) are weakly enforced, and both exempt poultry, which make up 98% of U.S. land animals raised for food.
These issues, which I raised in my 1984 book "Farm Animals: Husbandry, Behavior, and Veterinary Practice (Viewpoints of a Critic)," are at last beginning to be addressed. Animal welfare and health should take precedence over productivity and profitability.
LOOK FOR THIS 'ANIMAL WELFARE' LABEL
The Global Animal Partnership (globalanimalpartnership.org) is one of the largest animal welfare food-labeling programs in North America. Seek their "Animal Welfare Certified" label on any animal products you purchase. Also look for it on pet foods, such as veterinarian Dr. Bob Goldstein's Wisdom dog foods and treats (earthanimal.com). Our dog relished his turkey kibble recipe, which smells delectable and which I can feed him in good conscience.
DEAR DR. FOX: My 8-year-old cat, Mia, got sick after eating food from Evanger's Organics (the Turkey and Butternut Squash variety) last week. She began drinking copious amounts of water and urinating heavily. At first, I didn't connect it to the food, and thought she might be going into renal failure. But Mia set me straight when I tried to feed her the same food again. She seemed to say to me, "ARE YOU CRAZY?"
She seems to have improved now; her energy has been pretty good since yesterday.
I informed the store where I obtained the "food." They asked if I wanted to return it, and I said, "For now, I'm keeping it as evidence." Is there a lab that can test this cat food for toxins?
For now, I will start using your cat food recipe. Can I substitute quinoa for the rice, since rice has arsenic in it? Can I substitute sesame seeds for calcium carbonate/bone meal? Bone meal contains lead, and calcium carbonate is inorganic rock. -- D.W., Ashland, Oregon
DEAR D.W.: I am glad your cat rejected a second serving of the cat food that made her sick. I would suspect endotoxins from degraded/contaminated meat.
I believe that this company had some serious issues a few years back with a batch of their food being contaminated with pentobarbital (a drug used to euthanize animals). This was originally discovered by a pet owner in Washington state when her dog died. Oregon State University performed some lab work in this case, in partnership with the FDA. I would start by contacting the vet college at Oregon State.
As to feeding your cat my basic home-prepared recipe, I have a new version that no longer includes rice (see my website, drfoxonehealth.com). You will also find safer sources of calcium in the recipe.
Keep me posted if you do get toxicity tests done.
(Send all mail to animaldocfox@gmail.com or to Dr. Michael Fox in care of Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. The volume of mail received prohibits personal replies, but questions and comments of general interest will be discussed in future columns.
Visit Dr. Fox’s website at DrFoxOneHealth.com.)