When I shared a story recently about a particularly vulgar piece of anonymous mail sent to me, I wanted to offer an observation about the change I’ve seen in public discourse.
Advertisement
Journalists have always had to field some angry responses. In my experience, that hate mail has become openly bigoted lately.
I was surprised by how many readers responded to that column. Nearly a hundred people wrote or called to say this anonymous letter upset them, and to offer a counter-perspective. Some even pulled out their own embossed stationery and note cards, while one reader sent a two-page handwritten letter. Many said they felt “compelled” to respond and shared their own backgrounds and reasons why. A 76-year-old gentleman said he was educated in Catholic schools and the only religions he had known of back then were “Protestant, Catholic and Jewish.”
“Your last weekend’s column haunted me ... Please don’t let it hurt your feelings or change you in any way,” he wrote. Rest assured, I wasn’t hurt nor intending to change.
Another older reader said she appreciated learning about Muslim traditions and my family’s cultural background from reading the column for years.
“I often think that, despite our age difference, we would be friends if we met,” she wrote. I’m inclined to agree whenever readers suggest we would be friends in real life. I’m a huge fan of newspaper readers as it is. And subscribers, I love. Even those who have never agreed with a single word I’ve written.
The writers of many of the notes said they were worried about the emboldened bigots and demise of civility, especially since the last election. One woman shared her coping strategy: “I think the best way ... is to get politically involved, volunteer in the community and do random acts of kindness. I will not sink to their level,” she wrote.
Her words inspired me to try to be kinder.
To be fair, there were a minority of dissenters: Those who said they see far worse vitriol from the left, and those who said journalists were bringing personal attacks upon themselves for their “biased” coverage.
I’ll leave it for readers to judge where they see most of the personal attacks and bigotry coming from. But, it is startling to see the two different realities that exist in our country right now. We used to be able to agree on a very basic set of facts and values, but that doesn’t seem to be the case anymore. It seems that many of us can look out of the window and see rain, while others will insist it’s sunny.
A surprising number of those who wrote described themselves as white and then apologized for the bigoted mail others had sent. I appreciate their sentiment, but I hope they know that I would never hold an entire group responsible for the behavior of the fringe elements. As a Muslim, I’ve seen how collective blame works. Even those who abhor the hateful actions of a few are made to feel guilty. That’s always unfair.
A few readers shared that their families received anonymous angry letters in their mail after a letter to the editor they had written was published. It was disconcerting that a stranger had gone to the trouble of looking up the address of private citizens, writing and mailing an insulting letter simply because he or she disagreed with their opinions.
Unfortunately, there will always be those who try to stifle other people’s voices.
As an antidote, there were notes like this one: “I read your articles every week, and I agree with some and disagree with others, but I will always defend your right to express your opinion ... I’m a 71-year-old Army veteran who will always defend anyone’s right to express their opinion in a civil manner.”
Several readers who sent encouraging notes asked me to show their emails to my daughter, who had seen the original letter I wrote about. I printed out those emails and made sure she read them. Your responses taught her an even more important lesson -- that there are far more good and decent people in the world than those who seek to divide us.
I didn’t expect the avalanche of reactions you sent.
Thank you for flooding my inbox with hope.