DEAR HARRIETTE: My 17-year-old daughter recently got into a car accident. Thankfully, she wasn’t seriously hurt, but the car was totaled. After talking to her about what happened, it became clear that the accident was due to her not paying attention: She was distracted, and it cost her.
Now that the dust has settled, she’s asking my husband and me to buy her a new car. She seems to expect that we’ll replace it like we’re upgrading her phone, and I’m struggling with how entitled she sounds. I understand that having a car is important for her independence, job and social life, but I also feel strongly that this is an opportunity to teach her some real-world responsibility. I told her that we’re willing to help with the cost, but she needs to contribute financially as well, whether that means saving up from her part-time job or doing extra work around the house. She, of course, is frustrated and thinks we’re being unfair. She says she’s already learned her lesson from the crash, but I’m not so sure. Am I being too harsh? -- Learn the Lesson
DEAR LEARN THE LESSON: Your daughter absolutely should have repercussions due to her accident. She needs to step up and help figure out how she can have a car again. Yes, she should have to help pay for it. One way to approach this might be to offer to match dollar for dollar whatever money she is willing and able to put toward the vehicle.
Sure, it’s frustrating, but so was the crash that totaled the car, raised your insurance bill and required the purchase of a new car. She may think she has learned her lesson, but she has a long way to go.