DEAR HARRIETTE: My sister “Ruth” and I were both supposed to help a friend settle into her new home, but Ruth backed out after getting a last-minute invite to brunch. Our plans to help our friend had been scheduled long in advance. Ruth’s SUV was packed with furniture and other items that we were expected to bring over, so she asked if she could borrow my car and meet me at our friend’s place later. I agreed reluctantly and drove Ruth’s car over with all of our friend’s belongings.
Later that day, Ruth got into a minor fender bender in my car. She was not hurt, thankfully, and there was no damage to my car, but two months later, my insurance skyrocketed! I recognize that these things can happen to anyone, but Ruth has a history of blowing off commitments for fun, and frankly, I’m sick of it. My insurance has tripled to an enormous amount. I spoke to her about how careless she is, and she was immediately dismissive. Is it fair that I demand she regularly pay the difference between my previous rate and my post-accident rate? What is a realistic remedy here? -- Irresponsible Sister
DEAR IRRESPONSIBLE SISTER: It is fair to ask your sister to pay the difference in your insurance costs, though she may not do it. Demand it anyway. Have a frank conversation with her about her recklessness and its impact on others.
In the future, do not allow Ruth to borrow your car, and remember her flakiness when making plans.