DEAR HARRIETTE: My boyfriend is incredibly stingy. We get along well in many ways, but when it comes to money, he’s not what I expected. He never offers to pay for our dates. It’s not that I mind splitting the bill sometimes, but I’ve noticed that he never makes any effort to treat me, even on special occasions. He’s also extremely reluctant to share anything. If we’re out to eat, he won’t offer me a sip of his drink or a bite of his meal, which feels selfish. I’m not the type to demand material things, but I do expect a certain level of generosity and a willingness to share in a relationship.
Growing up, I saw my parents model a different type of relationship: My dad was always a gentleman, taking care of my mom and showing his affection through little acts of giving, whether it was paying for dinner or simply being thoughtful. Seeing my boyfriend behave so differently from what I’m used to has made me question whether he truly cares about me. I know that people show love in different ways, but it’s hard not to feel like his stinginess is a reflection of his feelings for me. I fear this might be a shallow concern because it revolves around money. Am I overreacting, or is this something I should be more concerned about? -- Stingy Boyfriend
DEAR STINGY BOYFRIEND: Your boyfriend clearly grew up with different ideas about how to behave in a relationship. Tell him a story about your father and how he treated your mother. Describe what thoughtfulness looked like to you. Ask him why he never treats you to meals or contributes financially. Listen to learn his thinking, and ask him if he would consider being more generous.