DEAR MISS MANNERS: My boyfriend gave me a pair of diamond earrings for Christmas. They are substantial in size. He also bought diamond jewelry for his daughters and mother.
Upon closer inspection, I saw that the earrings are set in silver, and I am quite sure they are not real diamonds. He is convinced that they are. That is the issue: He spent quite a bit of money, thinking he was buying diamonds.
I will wear them, regardless. But I feel bad knowing he has likely been scammed. I don't want to tell him, but at the same time, I hate to see him waste so much money on something he was fooled into believing was genuine.
Should I stay silent?
GENTLE READER: Have you never heard the adage, "Don't look a gift horse in the mouth"?
Yes, you could have the jewelry appraised, find out how much the gentleman paid for it, and, if there is a great disparity, tell him that he was made a fool of.
Miss Manners fails to see what this would accomplish, aside from discouraging him from trying again to please you with presents.