life

Sometimes, It’s Best to Say Goodbye

Miss Manners by by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Miss Manners | September 25th, 2001

DEAR MISS MANNERS: My daughter's wedding five months ago was very small, and only family was invited except for a couple whom we have known for 31 years, who are considered "family." These people have always been there for us, and we have been there for them.

At the wedding, my friends got drunk, and Mrs. X lay on the floor twice and received lots attention from the other guests (many of whom were physicians). Her husband was loud and mean to me and to some guests. They had a very negative effect on the wedding.

My daughter and her husband are very hurt, and my daughter has difficulty when speaking to them. Another reason for her negative feelings is they never acknowledged her marriage with a gift or a card. I, on the other hand, am treating them as though nothing happened.

Last week, Mr. and Mrs. X had a party to celebrate her daughters' graduation from medical school. Only family and selected friends were invited. His children (from a previous marriage) and I were not invited. Mrs. X told me his children are hurt. I am not mad, but I am hurt. I need an unbiased opinion -- do I continue treating them as though these things have not occurred?

GENTLE READER: In the hope that they will continue to be "there" for you? Why? Does your floor seem empty without her? Are your family celebrations dull without his loudly abusing you and the other guests?

Miss Manners just wants to make sure she understands the problem. Much as she appreciates loyalty to old friends, she is having a difficult time believing that you hope to get back into their good graces, such as they are.

If these are ordinarily considerate, well-behaved, affectionate friends who have suddenly spun out of control, surely you should be alarmed about them, rather than miffed to be left out of their shenanigans. If this is just the way they have always been, and you truly are hurt that they are distancing themselves from you -- well, that's what's giving Miss Manners trouble.

No matter. Although these people know something about social crimes, it is only a misdemeanor to fail to include friends at a family party. But it does mean that they are distancing themselves, and you would do well to accept this by stepping back as well. This is best done quietly, neither challenging them with perfidy, nor dancing in the streets because they have released you.

DEAR MISS MANNERS: I operate a daycare out of my home. I am having a problem with a parent who doesn't seem to want to leave when picking up her son. At times this parent will stay for an hour trying to talk to me.

How do I tell this mom that I do not want to be her friend? I do not like to get too personal with the parents of the kids that I provide care for. This parent calls me just to talk on a regular basis. If I tell her I can't talk right then, she just calls me later. Please help me with this problem.

GENTLE READER: The threshold that is supposed to separate the workplace from private space has become seriously eroded everywhere, and here you are trying to maintain it in your home, where you welcome your clients' children. Miss Manners offers you her sympathy and her admiration.

The solution is to revert to professional behavior. Toward parents, who will sometimes need legitimate access, that means establishing calling hours and sticking to them: "I take calls from parents from 8:30 to 9, but you can always e-mail me about your concerns." Toward children, it means continuing instruction until they are out the door: "Brandon, it's time to go home with your mother now, and I'll see you in the morning."

:

life

Call the Man ‘Doctor’

Miss Manners by by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Miss Manners | September 20th, 2001

DEAR MISS MANNERS: My boyfriend's father is a physician, and I have always addressed him as "Mister" since it comes naturally to me. I am 18 years old, and have been dating my boyfriend for three years, and he always makes a point of correcting me in front of his father, saying that I should call him "Doctor." Is it rude or bad manners for me to call him "Mister" when he is a physician?

GENTLE READER: Miss Manners certainly considers it rude of you repeatedly to ignore your beau's wishes, and presumably those of his father, on the grounds that it is more important for you to do what "comes naturally." Especially when your natural inclination in this case is to be incorrect. As a matter of fact, medical doctors are properly addressed as "doctor," even socially.

DEAR MISS MANNERS: Back when I was preparing to marry, toward the end of the Second Punic War, a bridal shower was a gathering at which the future bride's girlfriends "showered" her with small, utilitarian gifts that fit into the budgets of students or young working women: pot holders, dish towels, assorted little kitchen gadgets and the like. For a real splurge, several guests might chip in for an inexpensive negligee. Serious house wares, such as electrical appliances, place settings of china or silver, casserole dishes, wooden salad sets or silver candlesticks were considered wedding presents.

Now that several of my friends' daughters are getting married, I have been invited to a series of showers organized not by young, impecunious friends of the bride but by groups of prosperous, middle-aged friends or relatives of the young couple's parents. The guests are overwhelmingly women of my own age, some of whom have made special trips from out of town to attend. The refreshments are catered. And the gifts are of the category I remember receiving for my wedding, many of them selected from the registry of the bride's preferences.

The main entertainment is a game of bingo played while the guest of honor opens her gifts. The squares on the cards contain not numbers but the names of various gifts. As the bride opens each package, the guests cover the appropriate square.

I have felt a great deal of pressure to join my friends in celebrating their daughters' forthcoming weddings and therefore have attended. Because the gifts are opened publicly, I have felt compelled to bring something that I consider to be at the lower end of the wedding present range. Then, when the wedding invitation arrives, I have felt compelled to give another gift of equal or greater cost.

This has put me in a sour mood and has made me wonder whether it is really necessary to give two substantial gifts for a single marriage. On the one hand, I have been invited to two celebratory social events, and I do wish the young people well. On the other hand, none of these youngsters is economically deprived, and I feel shaken down at these events. What do you advise?

GENTLE READER: The fact that Miss Manners feels exactly as you do about the over-blown shower does not justify accepting an invitation and refusing to comply with its terms. On the other hand, no one in her right mind should be subjected to playing Gimme Bingo.

Surely there is a less arduous way you can show your good will for the young people. A letter expressing your good wishes would do that, but in cases where you are especially close, you could invite the bride to lunch and give her a chance to tell you all those wedding details she is unable to get anyone besides her mother to listen to.

:

life

Charities Insult Donors

Miss Manners by by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
by Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Miss Manners | September 18th, 2001

DEAR MISS MANNERS: Perhaps you know the drill that charity organizations use to rate their donors: Large donors are "Patrons" and "Benefactors," while smaller donors are merely "Associates."

Although I believe in giving to charity, I was recently between jobs and could not give that much. A $15 check was a real sacrifice for me at that time. I felt slighted when I had to check off the "Associate" box when I had stretched my budget to include charitable giving.

I am not asking whether this fundraising practice is rude; I know that it's always rude to slight or demean people because they have less money. My question is, how much slack do these organizations deserve (because their cause is good) before I decide to stop having anything to do with them? Is there any hope for etiquette in nonprofit fundraising?

GENTLE READER: Not as long as they can succeed in getting donors like you to take this gimmick seriously.

Miss Manners is afraid that it is as common in the nonprofit organizations as it is in business to look only at the bottom line, giving scant consideration to the feelings of the customers -- or even to the possibility of driving away small donors before they are in a position to give more. Doing good is never an excuse for behaving badly, but it is particularly unwise in an organization that depends on appealing to people's own good nature.

Unfortunately, they have discovered that appealing to baser instincts also works. Miss Manners can't imagine why you are insulted to be called an "associate," but if they can make you feel shamed at this rating, perhaps to the extent of giving more than you can afford, they will continue it.

Sensibly, irritating fund-raising practices should have no more effect on what charities you support than objectionable advertising should steer you away from good products. But they both do. If the listings annoy you, you can escape them by asking that your donation remain anonymous.

DEAR MISS MANNERS: I am currently unemployed, single, with no children. I would like to be employed again. What do I say to people when they ask, "What do you do?" In this society, it is what you do that matters, and not much else. When appropriate, I tell people I'm unemployed, and I will also ask them if they know of any jobs. However, there are times when I feel it is inappropriate to answer the question with "I'm unemployed." Some people subsequently treat me like pond scum once they find out I'm unemployed. (You'd be surprised how often this happens.) I would like to have an appropriate response to "What do you do?"

GENTLE READER: Even when this question is posed as an innocuous conversation-opener, and not by one of those dreadful people who uses social occasions to angle for professional advantage, Miss Manners finds it tedious. She was about to sympathize with you and advise you to treat it as if it were the more general question, "Tell me about yourself."

But hold on. You want to use social occasions to angle for a professional advantage. If you want to hear about job opportunities, you are going to have to tell people what kinds of jobs you can do. The upbeat way of saying "I'm unemployed and desperate" is "As a matter of fact, I'm just now looking for something challenging."

:

Next up: More trusted advice from...

  • A Place of Peace
  • Is My Self-Care Selfish?
  • Transportable Tranquility
  • 7 Day Menu Planner for March 26, 2023
  • 7 Day Menu Planner for March 19, 2023
  • 7 Day Menu Planner for March 12, 2023
  • The Worst Part of Waiting for College Admissions
  • Taking a Life-Changing Risk
  • Reversing the Rise in Dangerous Driving
UExpressLifeParentingHomePetsHealthAstrologyOdditiesA-Z
AboutContactSubmissionsTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
©2023 Andrews McMeel Universal