DEAR SOMEONE ELSE’S MOM: When my three-year-old drew on my friend’s new cream-colored sofa with a bright green crayon during a playdate a few weeks ago, I felt so guilty. I told my friend that, of course, I would pay to have the sofa cleaned, and she told me she would let me know how much it costs. Unfortunately, she told me it is a kind of fabric that can only be professionally cleaned.
The bill for it came to nearly $325! When I told her that seemed expensive, she told me she had the armchair cleaned too, since the two toddlers had been playing near it that same day as my daughter marked her sofa, and that she found green crayon marks on that chair as well after my daughter and I went home.
We were both in the room with the two girls the whole time they were playing, and I know for a fact that my daughter was never near the chair. I told my friend that, and she said that she doesn’t know how the marks could have gotten there, then, since her daughter only ever had a pink crayon that day.
I got angry, and told her I don’t think my daughter had anything to do with the marks on the chair. When we finished the call I was still so mad, I texted my husband, and he agreed with me there was no way we should have to pay for cleaning both pieces of furniture. And my mother said my friend could have had a whole new chair for that price.
It has been two weeks now, and I Venmoed her two-thirds of the cost of the cleaning, and she called me asking when I would send her the rest. I told her I was only going to pay for the sofa part of the cleaning, and she hung up on me.
We haven’t spoken since, and that means our girls, who are besties have not been able to play together.
Do you think I did anything wrong, or did my maybe ex-friend just take advantage of the situation with the sofa to get the chair cleaned as well, which is what we all think? --- SOFA ONLY
DEAR SOFA ONLY: Disagreements over money matters have ruined countless relationships, and it looks like that’s where your friendship’s headed now.
I don’t see this as a matter of one of you being more in the right or wrong than the other. When small children are involved things can happen in the blink of an eye, and it’s possible your friend is honestly as convinced your daughter’s crayon did the damage to the chair as you are your daughter was never near the chair during the visit. What might have made a difference is if the marks on the chair were mentioned at the time they were discovered, and certainly before the bill was sent to you.
It’s now up to both you and your friend to decide if this disagreement is worth ending your and your daughters’ friendships over.
Need advice? Please send your questions to Someone Else’s Mom at AskSomeoneElsesMom@gmail.com.