DEAR SOMEONE ELSE’S MOM: A classmate and I both landed an awesome summer internship with one of the top law firms in DC the summer before our final year in law school. We were both assigned to work with the team of one of the firm’s top partners, who was working on an extremely high-profile case at the time. It was one of those cases that was constantly in the news.
One late night, after we had both been working since early in the morning, we found a file containing some very sensitive information on the counter in the breakroom. As soon as I saw it, I realized I was the one who had accidentally left it there, but I knew it would cost me the internship if I fessed up it was me who made the mistake.
Instead, I let on that I had no idea how it got there, which made my classmate believe she had been the one who unwittingly left such sensitive material in such a public place, since we were the only ones on the floor at the time. If it had been found by someone else, it would have meant huge trouble for several people, including us, so we agreed to keep quiet about it.
She felt so bad about “her” mistake, that she had a mini-meltdown, and ended up terminating her own internship.
Fortunately, she went on to graduate with honors, pass the bar on her first try, and snag a spot as an associate with another top flight firm.
So although my failing to come clean didn’t ultimately cost her anything, it still really bothers me all these years later, especially when she and I get together and start talking about old times.
Do you think my telling her the truth about what happened that summer would be a dumb thing to do at this late date? --- DO I FESS UP?
DEAR DO I FESS UP?: You need to ask yourself why telling your old classmate and fellow intern what really happened would make any difference to either of you at this point. Beyond giving yourself a chance to clear your conscience, as I see it, the greatest good would be in your friend’s being able to know she wasn’t at fault after years of believing she did something wrong. While things went well for her overall, her internship that one summer did not.
I think the only way you can move forward in your friendship is through your telling her what really happened that night. If she’s the forgiving kind, then your unburdening yourself not only relieves your conscience, but more importantly, allows her to know she wasn’t to blame for what happened back when you were working together.
Be prepared for some serious backlash if you do move forward with the confession. Your conscience will be clear, but her exoneration may come at the cost of your friendship, since it will be her choice to forgive or not.
Should you choose to keep silent, the price of holding onto your secret is the wedge already in place in your relationship caused by your guilt.