DEAR SOMEONE ELSE’S MOM: I have always had at least one dog in my life. Right now I have a lab and a dachshund, which is a funny, but very gentle, loving pair of best friends.
I have a new friend I made through my book club. She is new to the area and we really hit it off. On the evenings when the club meets some of us continue hanging out even after the official meetings by going for coffee or occasionally a drink.
The more time I spend with this woman, the more we discover we have in common. Like me, she is from the Midwest, went to school for healthcare management, and is taking time off to be home with her baby.
What I also found out about her is that she is terrified of dogs — any dogs. She had a bad experience with a neighbor’s dog attacking her when she was a child, and she has more than the scars you can see on her arm and leg from the experience.
I desperately want to move this new friendship forward, but it feels so one-sided when she has my daughter and me over to her place, as she has done for lunch a few times, but she has told me she can’t even be in a house where there are dogs, even if they’re secured nowhere near where we would be with our babies. I want to be able to repay her hospitality, and let our kids play in our playroom and in our backyard.
She is fine with the one-sided visits, and I always bring something for everyone to eat, but as much as I understand she had a bad time when she was small, I have trouble not taking it a little bit personally, and thinking she may just be using her fear of dogs as an excuse to not come to my home. We live in what’s considered the far edge of the city, and it isn’t as upscale as where she lives, but how much should I press her to come out my way, or do I just leave it go? --- IS IT ONLY MY DOGS?
DEAR IS IT ONLY MY DOGS?: I’ve known several people who have a true, deep-rooted fear of dogs. Like with your new friend, there’s usually a backstory of a traumatic experience that makes it impossible for them to be comfortable around dogs, even of the most gentle and non-threatening nature.
Given what I’ve seen in those with this phobia, I don’t believe you should doubt the sincerity of your friend’s claim that she can’t be anywhere near dogs. So long as it’s giving you and your children time together, then why not continue meeting at her home for now?
You might also explore some other options that possibly would work for you both. While parks or playgrounds aren’t the best bets because of the high likelihood of dogs being present, perhaps you could agree on locations such as shopping malls or local rec centers, where the possibility of running into dogs is more remote. Since these days, anywhere you go has a chance of being more pet-friendly than it used to be, doing a little reconnoitering of alternatives on your own seems like a good idea.