DEAR DR. BLONZ: The bread offerings at my market continue to expand with not only white and various types of wheat, but other grains and a variety of gluten-free options. I have no issues with gluten, but I remain confused about the relative nutritional merits of all these various bread types. -- B.L., Sun City, Arizona
Advertisement
DEAR B.L.: To better understand these breads, it will help to know a little about the wheat grain, or kernel. The kernel consists of the bran, the endosperm and the germ (tinyurl.com/qjbdk9f).
The bran is the protective outer shell of the grain, composed primarily of a nondigestible dietary fiber (bran) and a small amount of B vitamins. The endosperm, which is mostly starch (carbohydrate) with small amounts of protein, vitamins and minerals, is the central ingredient in the bread-making process. The germ is the embryo inside the grain; if the intact grain were to be planted, the germ would grow into a new plant. The germ contains most of wheat's vitamins and minerals, plus a small amount of essential oils: the nutrients needed by the wheat to fuel development until it can begin getting them from sun and soil. Because there are unsaturated oils in the germ, the wheat grain evolved to include vitamin E and other antioxidants to keep the fats from going rancid.
The internal contents of the grain are used to make bread. Cracked, crushed and whole-wheat flours all contain the entire wheat grain. In cracked wheat, the grains are cut in angular pieces; in crushed wheat, the grains get, well, crushed; and in whole-wheat flour, the entire grain is milled together. Each of these flours create breads of differing consistencies, but comparable nutritional value.
White flour, on the other hand, consists of the endosperm without the bran or wheat germ. Aside from the fact that it's a carbohydrate, it offers less in terms of native nutritional value. For this reason, white flours are usually enriched with added niacin, riboflavin, thiamin and iron to bring them up to the levels found in whole-wheat flour. Unless purposefully added, other naturally occurring wheat nutrients -- including magnesium, zinc, vitamin B6, vitamin E, folate and fiber -- are usually not present in white flour.
To find the healthiest bread options, you will have to read labels carefully. All flours made from the wheat grain can be called "wheat" flour, so it is perfectly legitimate for manufacturers to use the terms "white flour" and "wheat flour" interchangeably.
Don't be fooled by a bread's color: Some companies use white flour, legitimately call it wheat flour, but then add caramel coloring to make the bread appear to be whole-grain. On the flip side, whole-grain breads tend to be heavier in texture, so bread makers often add gluten to make it softer. Some do this by adding white flour, which has more gluten per unit weight, while others add pure gluten to the mix.
The healthiest products are the least refined and have the greatest percentage of whole grains. Look for "cracked," "crushed" or "whole-grain wheat" at the top of the ingredient list, regardless of how many different grains are used.
Whatever your choice, aim for a product that has at least one gram of fiber per slice. Make it a habit to check the Nutrition Facts panel and the list of ingredients when comparing products.
Send questions to: "On Nutrition," Ed Blonz, c/o Universal Uclick, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO, 64106. Send email inquiries to questions@blonz.com. Due to the volume of mail, personal replies cannot be provided.