DEAR DR. BLONZ: My best friend, his roommate and I eat the same basic foods. The three of us are similar in size, age and ethnic background, and we exercise using the same routines. In the past, we measured our intake and checked food composition tables and found that we eat just about the same number of calories every day. The reason for this question is that, despite these similarities, our weights and body shapes have diverged over the past years. How is it that people with such similar caloric intakes can end up with such different weights and shapes? -- F.S., Newark, New Jersey
DEAR F.S.: Food composition databases are helpful because they provide useful information about what's in the foods we eat. There is marginal precision for given food items as individual nutrients and calories are averages that blend variations between varieties, growing regions and practices, seasonal weather, and production and packaging methods.
On labels or databases, calories per serving are theoretical calculations of potential energy for an average individual. The efficiency with which a fixed number of calories gets used, however, varies from one body type to another. It's analogous to the way miles per gallon can vary among different types of automobiles driving the same routes.
One's basal metabolism, which is the number of calories used while the body is at rest, tends to rise as the amount of muscle in the body goes up. This is because muscle is active tissue. Fat (adipose) tissue, by contrast, is inactive. Going back to an automobile analogy, this would be similar to how a car with an eight-cylinder engine burns more gas than a six- or four-cylinder engine when idling and during acceleration. Bodies with different genetic makeups, compositions and fitness levels also behave differently.
Other factors that help to explain individual variations include age, sex, level of physical activity and the efficiency with which one digests and absorbs food. All these can affect how a given number of calories gets handled by a particular body. The key contribution of exercise -- especially that designed to support muscles -- is that, in addition to burning calories, it can increase the amount of muscle in the body, which will burn calories even when you are at rest. For more on fitness and different types of exercise, see b.link/sfhbd8h.
As is true with most aspects of life, some people have to work harder to accomplish the same fitness goals. Where weight is concerned, though, one's value system should not get bogged down with comparisons to others. Rather, we should remain focused on doing the best with the hand we've been dealt.
Send questions to: "On Nutrition," Ed Blonz, c/o Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. Send email inquiries to questions@blonz.com. Due to the volume of mail, personal replies cannot be provided.